Plenty of cartridges get a reputation before they ever see real use. They show up in forums, gun shop counters, and marketing blurbs with big numbers and big claims. On paper, they sound like they can do everything short of field-dressing the deer for you. But the truth tends to hit after you pull the trigger a few times or actually carry the thing into the field. Some of these “powerful” rounds hit hard—once. Others run out of gas before they even get going. Either way, you won’t find them in a lot of repeat hunts. Here’s why they keep getting benched.
.17 WSM
The .17 Winchester Super Magnum shows off on the spec sheet. It zips along faster than most rimfires and promises flat shooting with more punch than a .17 HMR. That’s great for paper or the occasional prairie dog. But get outside of perfect conditions, and it’s a different story. Wind tosses those tiny bullets around like dry leaves.
It might sound like a laser beam, but in real-world varmint hunting, that velocity fades fast and you’re left chasing shots. Ammo isn’t exactly everywhere either. Most folks who buy a .17 WSM find themselves grabbing their .22 Mag or .223 next time they head out.
.300 Blackout
This round has been marketed hard as the do-it-all solution for suppressed shooting, short barrels, and deer within 150 yards. And sure, it works—sort of. But it runs out of steam quick. Supersonic loads perform like a hot .30-30, and subsonics hit like a brick at 50 yards.
It’s fun for range time, and it makes sense for home defense with a can. But when you need reach or reliable expansion on game, .300 Blackout fizzles. A lot of hunters give it one try in the woods and go back to their .308 or 6.5.
.204 Ruger
The .204 Ruger is blisteringly fast and laser-flat—until the wind picks up or the shot stretches past 300 yards. That 32- or 40-grain bullet gets impressive speed but lacks staying power. It works great on paper, but furthest targets or larger varmints can expose its limitations.
Plenty of predator hunters tried the .204 thinking they’d found the new king of the prairie. But when coyotes kept running off or accuracy dropped past 250 yards, most went back to the .22-250 or .223. It’s a cool round but not the killer it’s hyped up to be.
.45 GAP
This one tried to be a more “compact” .45 ACP for modern pistols. The .45 GAP (Glock Auto Pistol) was built to mimic .45 performance in a smaller frame, but it never really caught on. It underdelivered on energy and left folks wondering what the point was.
Ammo is hard to find, recoil’s still snappy, and there’s no real gain over 9mm or .40 S&W. Most people who picked one up out of curiosity—or brand loyalty—wound up regretting it. It fizzled fast because it never solved a problem that actually existed.
.30 Carbine
There’s no denying the historical charm of the M1 Carbine. It’s lightweight and fun to shoot, and it saw a lot of action. But from a hunting standpoint, the .30 Carbine is pretty underwhelming. It throws a soft, round-nosed bullet with limited energy and poor expansion on game.
Folks try to use it for hogs or deer in thick brush and end up frustrated. It’s not that it can’t kill—it can—but shot placement has to be perfect, and bullet selection is limited. Most hunters who test it out once don’t come back for a second go.
.25-06 Remington
This one raises eyebrows because on paper, it looks like a deer hunter’s dream. Flat-shooting, fast, and capable of reaching out. But that speed comes at a price: barrel wear, picky loads, and brutal throat erosion if you shoot much. Add to that the recoil, which hits harder than a 6.5 Creedmoor with little extra benefit.
Hunters get sold on the velocity numbers but find it frustrating over time. Ammo options aren’t as broad, and many rifles don’t hold accuracy for long without rebarreling. It sounds like a long-range winner, but the maintenance and quirks wear thin fast.
7mm Remington Ultra Mag
This one shows up with all the punch and prestige of a magnum cartridge—and then turns into a wallet-draining headache. The 7mm RUM is fast, powerful, and overkill for almost everything you’d hunt in North America. It burns a mountain of powder, kicks like a mule, and eats barrels for lunch.
You might take it out once for elk, but packing that kind of recoil and weight through the mountains gets old quick. It’s more of a bench queen than a backcountry partner. For every guy bragging about it at the range, there’s one more selling it in the classifieds.
.458 SOCOM
This one sounds like it should flatten anything that walks. Designed for the AR-15 platform, the .458 SOCOM offers big-bore power in a familiar package. But performance drops hard outside of 100 yards. Accuracy is average, trajectory is awful, and ammo’s expensive.
It makes a satisfying boom and delivers energy—close up. But most folks who hunt with it quickly realize they’re limited in both distance and practicality. It’s a fun round for hogs or a suppressed rifle setup, but it fades fast once the novelty wears off.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
The worst deer rifles money can buy
Sidearms That Belong in the Safe — Not Your Belt
*This article was developed with AI-powered tools and has been carefully reviewed by our editors.
