The 1911 has been around for more than a century, but it’s still hanging on—especially with new models getting modern tweaks. Some folks swear by them for carry, others think they’re too outdated to bother with. So the question is: are modern 1911s really still practical for everyday carry, or are we just holding on for nostalgia? Here’s a breakdown of what’s working, what’s changed, and why some shooters still trust the old warhorse.
The Trigger Still Sets the Standard
Even with all the modern striker-fired options, few triggers feel as clean as a good 1911. The short, straight-back pull just feels natural, especially for precise shots.
It’s one of the main reasons folks still carry them. If you’ve ever tried one at the range, you probably get why people keep coming back to that trigger feel.
New Models Are More Reliable
Old-school 1911s were picky with ammo and could choke if not babied. These days, manufacturers have fixed a lot of those quirks, especially with polished feed ramps and tighter tolerances.
That said, some brands still get it wrong. A modern 1911 from a reputable maker is much more forgiving, but you still need to break it in and keep it clean.
They’re Still Heavy for Daily Carry
Let’s be honest—carrying a full-size steel 1911 all day can be a pain. Some folks can manage it, but it’s not as easy as clipping on a lightweight polymer pistol.
Compact models like the Commander or Officer-size help a bit, but you’re still looking at more weight than most modern carry guns. Holster choice matters a lot here.
Single-Stack Limits Your Capacity
Even the best 1911 is still stuck with a single-stack mag. Most .45 ACP models hold 7 or 8 rounds, and 9mm ones might squeeze in 9 or 10.
Compared to double-stack carry guns, you’re giving up capacity. For some, the tradeoff is worth it for accuracy and shootability. Others want more rounds, period.
Controls Are Familiar and Intuitive
One reason people like carrying 1911s is because the controls just make sense. The manual safety, mag release, and slide stop are all right where your fingers expect them.
If you’ve trained on a 1911, switching to something else can feel off. Muscle memory is real, and it’s part of what keeps this platform relevant.
Holster Support Is Still Strong
Even after all this time, you won’t struggle to find good holsters for a 1911. Whether it’s leather, kydex, or hybrid, almost every holster maker still supports them.
This makes it easy to carry how you want—inside the waistband, outside, shoulder rig—you name it. That kind of aftermarket support adds to the carry appeal.
Slim Profile Helps With Concealment
Despite the weight, the 1911 is actually easier to hide than some expect. That slim single-stack frame hugs the body and prints less than many chunkier pistols.
It’s especially true with a proper IWB holster and a cover garment that doesn’t cling. It’s not tiny, but it disappears better than you’d think.
It Requires a Bit More Maintenance
A 1911 isn’t the kind of gun you can just throw in a safe and forget about. It likes lube, it wants to be cleaned, and it doesn’t always play nice with neglect.
For folks who enjoy tinkering and maintaining their gear, that’s not a dealbreaker. But if you want something totally low maintenance, there are simpler options out there.
Ammo Costs Can Add Up
Most folks carry .45 ACP in their 1911, and let’s face it—.45 isn’t cheap. You’ll spend more to train with it than you would shooting 9mm or .380.
There are 1911s chambered in 9mm, and they’re gaining popularity for exactly that reason. But many still stick to the classic .45, cost and all.
It’s Still a Confidence Gun
At the end of the day, some people just shoot better with a 1911. It points naturally, feels good in hand, and inspires confidence. That matters.
If you’ve trained with it and trust it, there’s nothing wrong with carrying a 1911. Just know what you’re getting into—and don’t skip range time.
*This article was developed with AI-powered tools and has been carefully reviewed by our editors.
