Some calibers sound like a great idea when you’re shopping for a new rifle. They promise flat trajectories, low recoil, or long-range precision that’ll change your season. Then you take them hunting—and reality hits. Ammo’s impossible to find, recoil’s rougher than expected, or the cartridge just doesn’t perform the way it should in the field. By the end of the season, most hunters quietly put them back in the safe or trade them for something more practical. Every hunter’s had one—good on paper, frustrating in real life. These are the calibers that see a lot of excitement in the fall and a lot of dust by spring.
6.5 PRC
The 6.5 PRC makes a great first impression. It’s fast, flat, and accurate, and it feels like a natural upgrade from the 6.5 Creedmoor. Then you start paying for ammo—and watching your barrel life shrink. The PRC’s efficiency comes at the cost of heat and erosion, and the performance gain over the Creedmoor isn’t big enough to make up for it.
Many hunters find out that the extra velocity doesn’t make deer any deader, but it sure makes practice more expensive. It’s a precision shooter’s cartridge, not a do-everything hunting round, and most folks learn that lesson after one season.
.450 Bushmaster
The .450 Bushmaster was the hero of straight-wall cartridge zones for a few years. It hits hard and looks good on paper, but many hunters find it’s more headache than help. The recoil’s heavy, trajectory drops fast, and ammo isn’t cheap.
Inside 200 yards, it’ll hammer deer. Beyond that, it becomes guesswork. For many hunters, the novelty fades once they realize the .350 Legend offers similar results with less punishment and better follow-ups. The Bushmaster works—but it’s rough on both shoulders and wallets, which is why most drop it after a season of bruises.
.300 Winchester Magnum
The .300 Win Mag is legendary, and that reputation sells a lot of rifles. But plenty of hunters discover it’s more gun than they need. It hits hard on both ends and costs more per round than more manageable calibers like the .308 or .30-06.
It’s capable, sure—but most hunting shots aren’t past 300 yards. The recoil, muzzle blast, and expense outweigh the benefits for average-sized game. Many hunters love it for a year, then move to something that doesn’t make them flinch by Thanksgiving.
.28 Nosler
The .28 Nosler has incredible numbers and ballistic charts that make you dream about 800-yard shots. But after a season, most realize those stats come with a price—literally. The ammo is expensive, hard to find, and burns barrels faster than most hunters shoot them out.
It’s a long-range cartridge meant for serious competition or big-country elk hunts, not weekend whitetail trips. Once hunters compare the cost and kick to the minor real-world gains, the .28 Nosler ends up parked next to rifles they “might use again someday.”
.243 Winchester
The .243 Winchester seems like the perfect all-around deer cartridge—until it isn’t. It’s fast, accurate, and flat-shooting, but its lightweight bullets can struggle with penetration on bigger-bodied deer or hogs. Hunters often find they need perfect shot placement, and anything less leaves them tracking.
After a season of mixed results, many upgrade to something with more weight behind it, like the 7mm-08 or .308. The .243 is ideal for beginners and varmint hunters but often feels underpowered once experience grows.
6.8 Western
The 6.8 Western was marketed as the modern answer to the .270, but few hunters stuck with it. It’s powerful and accurate, but rifles and ammo are hard to come by. When you do find boxes, they’re pricey, and the ballistic improvement over the .270 Winchester isn’t worth the extra cost.
It’s a cartridge that came on strong, then faded quickly once hunters realized it didn’t offer enough benefit to replace what they already trusted. For most, the 6.8 Western becomes an interesting experiment—one that never makes it back into deer camp.
.224 Valkyrie
The .224 Valkyrie promised long-range precision from the AR platform, and for target shooters it sometimes delivers. But hunters expecting reliable downrange performance on game found it lacking. It’s too light for consistent penetration, and ammo availability has been inconsistent since launch.
Many who tried it for coyotes or deer wound up disappointed with terminal results and returned to the easier-to-find .223 or .22-250. It’s accurate, yes—but the real-world payoff doesn’t match the hype, and the price per box doesn’t help.
.300 PRC
The .300 PRC is a phenomenal long-range performer with modern ballistics and excellent design. But most hunters don’t need it—and that’s what they figure out fast. The ammo is costly, the recoil stout, and few shots in real hunting conditions require that kind of reach.
It’s ideal for precision shooters chasing mile-long targets, not whitetails at 200 yards. Many hunters try it out for a year, appreciate its accuracy, then go right back to their .308s or .30-06s. The juice isn’t worth the squeeze unless you truly shoot far.
.350 Legend
The .350 Legend was designed to meet straight-wall hunting laws, and it does that job well. But it also underwhelms a lot of hunters. Its accuracy drops fast past 150 yards, and energy levels fade quickly.
It’s an easy-shooting, affordable option for Midwest whitetail, but it doesn’t handle bigger game or longer shots gracefully. After one season, many hunters trade it for a more versatile rifle and never look back. It’s a good niche cartridge that too many people expected to do everything.
.17 HMR
The .17 HMR is a fun round for targets and small varmints, but plenty of hunters push it too far. It’s surgical on prairie dogs, but when bone or wind gets involved, it fails fast. After a season of unpredictable performance on anything bigger, most shooters retire it to the range.
It’s not the round’s fault—it was never meant for tough game. It simply lures hunters in with speed and accuracy, then reminds them why bullet weight still matters in the real world.
.25-06 Remington
The .25-06 has loyal fans, but it’s another caliber that leaves many first-timers underwhelmed. It shoots flat, hits hard enough for deer, and looks great on paper, but its recoil and muzzle blast are harsher than most expect.
You’ll get long shots, but the tradeoff is limited ammo options and a tendency to burn barrels with frequent shooting. It’s great in theory, but after a season, many hunters slide back to the .270 or .308 for convenience and comfort.
.260 Remington
The .260 Remington should have been a star. It balances recoil, accuracy, and efficiency beautifully—but timing and marketing killed it. Ammo’s hard to find, and rifles chambered for it are even scarcer now that the 6.5 Creedmoor dominates the shelf.
Most hunters who tried it loved how it shot but couldn’t justify sticking with a fading caliber that’s a pain to feed. After one season of searching every store for boxes, the .260 becomes another “great idea too late.”
.338 Winchester Magnum
The .338 Win Mag has serious authority, but most hunters realize fast that they don’t need that kind of power for whitetail or elk. The recoil is fierce, the rifles are heavy, and the ammo is expensive.
Unless you’re hunting something that bites back, it’s excessive. A .30-06 will do the same job with far less punishment. Hunters often buy into the hype of having “too much gun,” then learn the hard way that comfort and confidence matter more than raw horsepower.
.22-250 Remington
The .22-250 is one of the flattest-shooting varmint cartridges ever made, but its performance on larger game leaves something to be desired. It’s fast and fun at the range, but lightweight bullets limit its use on anything bigger than a coyote.
Hunters who try it for deer often find poor penetration or explosive impact with no exit. It’s an outstanding predator round, but it’s too specialized to be an all-around choice. Many first-time buyers learn that lesson after one season.
7mm Remington Ultra Magnum
The 7mm RUM is fast, powerful, and precise—but expensive, punishing, and hard on barrels. Hunters who love long-range shooting might stick with it, but most give up after realizing how costly it is to feed and how much recoil it delivers.
It’s a cartridge that looks like a dream in the catalog and feels like a chore in the field. You’ll find very few hunters who keep using it year after year. Most move back to something more manageable once the excitement fades.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
Calibers That Shouldn’t Even Be On the Shelf Anymore
Rifles That Shouldn’t Be Trusted Past 100 Yards
*This article was developed with AI-powered tools and has been carefully reviewed by our editors.
