There are guns that are “good” on paper and still a bad buy for you. Grip shape, trigger reach, how the sights track in recoil, whether the controls bite you or fight you—those are all personal. That’s why a handful of super-popular carry picks (Glock 19, SIG P365, etc.) still end up in the used case all the time.
Below are 15 guns I’d tell anybody to shoot before buying, because comfort and performance vary wildly from shooter to shooter.
Glock 43
The G43 is easy to carry, but it’s one of those pistols that can feel totally different depending on hand size and grip strength. Some guys shoot it like a laser. Other guys fight the gun the entire time—snappy recoil, short grip, and that “small gun wobble” that makes follow-up shots feel slower than they should. If your hands are bigger, you may also hate the way your pinky hangs or how the gun shifts under recoil.
Before you buy one, shoot it next to a slightly bigger option like a 43X or a Shield Plus. If the G43 makes you dread practice, it won’t get practiced with. That’s the real failure mode with small carry guns—people stop training because it’s not enjoyable.
Glock 26
The G26 is a proven carry gun, but that short grip is either “perfect” or “annoying,” and there’s not much in-between. Some shooters love that it disappears and still runs like a Glock. Others can’t get consistent reloads or consistent recoil control because the grip doesn’t give them enough leverage. If you shoot it with flush mags, it can feel like you’re pinching the gun during recoil.
Shoot it with the mags you’ll actually carry, not just a range mag with a big extension. Also try it from concealment if you can. A G26 can be fantastic, but it’s not an automatic win for every hand size and every shooting style.
SIG Sauer P365
The P365 is wildly popular for a reason, but it’s also a pistol that exposes grip mistakes fast. It’s small, it cycles quick, and if your grip isn’t consistent, the sights can feel like they’re bouncing more than you expect. Some people shoot it better than anything. Some people can’t keep groups tight once they speed up, even if they’re good shooters with bigger guns.
Try the standard P365, XL, and XMacro if possible. One will usually “click” more than the others. Don’t buy it based on what the internet carries—buy the size that you can actually run well when you’re tired and pushing the pace.
Springfield Hellcat / Hellcat Pro
Hellcats can shoot great, but the grip texture and geometry are love-or-hate. Some guys find the gun locks in and tracks flat. Other guys feel like it’s always moving in their hand, especially with sweaty palms or a high round-count session. The triggers can also feel different across samples, and that matters more on compact pistols than people admit.
The Pro version changes the whole feel because of the longer grip and sight radius. If you’re on the fence, shoot both. If you only shoot the micro version and hate it, you may mistakenly swear off the whole platform when the Pro might fit you better.
S&W M&P Shield Plus
The Shield Plus is a great carry size, but it’s another one where grip angle and trigger reach decide everything. Some shooters naturally index it and it just works. Others feel like they’re hunting for the dot or front sight every rep because the gun points differently for them than a Glock or SIG. The recoil impulse is also different than people expect for a slim gun.
Shoot it side-by-side with your current carry pistol, and pay attention to how quickly your sights settle. If the Shield feels “easy” for you, it’s a winner. If it feels like extra work, you’ll fight it long-term no matter how many people recommend it.
Canik TP9SF / Mete series
Caniks can be impressive for the price, but the trigger and grip shape can trick people into thinking they shoot better than they do—until they run drills at speed. Some shooters love the feel and can absolutely perform with them. Others find the gun feels great slow-fire, then gets a little chaotic under fast transitions and recoil management.
If you’re buying a Canik for carry, you really need to shoot it and confirm it runs the ammo you like and the mags you’ll trust. The “value” is real, but the fit and recoil behavior still has to work for your hands and your pace.
Walther PDP
The PDP has a strong reputation, but it’s also a pistol that some shooters find “too lively” because of slide mass and the way it returns to battery. For some people it tracks flat and fast. For others it feels like the dot is always making a bigger loop than they want. Grip texture and thickness can also be a dealbreaker if you’ve got smaller hands.
Don’t buy it because it feels awesome in the store. Shoot it. Run a few bill drills or failure-to-stop drills if you can. If it stays controllable for you when you’re moving quickly, you’ll love it. If not, it’ll frustrate you.
HK VP9
The VP9 is comfortable and can be very accurate, but the trigger feel and reset can hit different shooters differently. Some folks run it extremely well. Others feel like they can’t shoot it as fast as their Glock or M&P because the trigger rhythm doesn’t match them. The paddle vs. button mag release question (depending on model) also matters a lot.
HK ergonomics usually feel great…until they don’t. Shoot it, reload it, and do one-handed manipulations. If your hands love the controls, it’s a great gun. If you feel clumsy on it, don’t force it just because it “should” be good.
SIG Sauer P320 (carry and compact variants)
The P320 platform has a ton of variants, and that’s both the benefit and the trap. Different grip modules change everything—reach to the trigger, how the gun points, how the recoil feels. Some shooters swear it’s their best pistol. Others never feel fully locked in. A P320 that fits poorly can feel mushy in recoil and slow in transitions.
If you’re buying a P320, you need to shoot the exact configuration or at least confirm grip module size. The wrong grip size can make a good shooter feel inconsistent. The right grip size can make the gun feel like it was built for you.
CZ P-10 C
The P-10 C is a strong performer, but CZ grip shape is not universal. Some shooters get an incredible natural point and love the trigger feel. Others feel like the gun sits “low” or “different” and their support hand never feels perfect. Also, the way the gun returns in recoil can feel flatter than a Glock to some and more “bouncy” to others.
Shoot it and pay attention to your first shot from the holster and your split times. If you’re naturally landing sights without hunting, it’s a great buy. If you’re constantly adjusting your grip, that’s a warning sign.
FN 509
The FN 509 line is durable and proven, but the grip texture and trigger feel can be a dealbreaker depending on the shooter. Some people hate how aggressive the texture feels. Others love it because it locks the gun in. Trigger feel varies across models, and if you’re trigger-sensitive, you need to shoot it rather than assuming it’s “good enough.”
Also, the 509 can feel blockier in the hand than other compacts. If it fills your hand in a good way, you’ll shoot it well. If it feels like a brick, you’ll never love it, and that matters because the gun you love is the gun you’ll practice with.
Beretta APX A1
The APX A1 can be a sleeper, but the grip and trigger break feel can throw people off. Some shooters do great with it. Others feel like they’re always fighting the trigger wall or the reset rhythm. The slide shape and manipulation feel also matter if you do a lot of one-handed or off-hand work.
This is a perfect “shoot it first” pistol because the value can be excellent, but only if it fits you. If it doesn’t, you’ll end up trying to convince yourself it was a smart buy because the price was good. Fit beats price every time.
1911 Commander-size (any brand)
Commander-size 1911s are classic, but they’re also extremely sensitive to how you shoot and what you expect. The grip safety, thumb safety, trigger feel, and recoil impulse are either perfect for you—or they make you feel like you’re constantly managing the gun instead of shooting. Some folks shoot 1911s better than anything. Others can’t run them fast without fumbling safety manipulations.
Shoot one with the exact sights and trigger you’re considering. Also shoot it from concealment. If you’re not naturally consistent with safeties and grip, don’t buy it as a “project.” Buy what you can run today.
S&W J-Frame 642 / 442
A J-frame is the definition of “shoot it first.” On paper it’s small, simple, reliable. In real life, many people can’t shoot it well—heavy trigger, tiny sights, sharp recoil, and a grip that’s not forgiving. Some shooters are absolute hammers with a J-frame. Most people aren’t, and they find out after they already spent the money.
If you want a J-frame, rent one and shoot it with your defensive load. If you can’t keep hits where you need them at realistic distances, that gun is going to live in a drawer. It’s a great tool for the right shooter. It’s a bad purchase for the wrong one.
Ruger LCR (any caliber)
The LCR has a different feel than a J-frame, and that’s exactly why you need to shoot it before buying. Some people love the trigger feel and shoot it better than a Smith. Others hate the grip shape or how it recoils, especially in .357. The gun can be very shootable in .38 with the right load, but it’s still a small revolver with real recoil and a real trigger.
Shoot it, then shoot it again when you’re a little fatigued. That’s when small revolvers show you the truth. If you can still run it clean and keep hits consistent, it’s a solid choice. If it falls apart after a few cylinders, don’t force it.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
