You’ve heard the pitch before—match-grade barrel, tuned trigger, tight tolerances. But when you finally get that rifle on paper, your groups look like a shotgun pattern. Not every “tack driver” lives up to the sales pitch, and some rifles throw more blame than bullets. Sometimes it’s poor bedding, wandering zero, or finicky ammo preference. Other times, it’s a platform that wasn’t all that dialed-in to begin with. Either way, you end up second-guessing your scope, your stance, and your sanity. If you’ve ever bought a rifle that sounded too good to be true, you’re not alone. Here are a dozen guns that claim precision but tend to hand you a list of excuses instead.
Mossberg MVP Predator
On paper, it checks a lot of boxes—fluted barrel, adjustable LBA trigger, and AR mag compatibility. But in practice, the MVP Predator has a habit of walking its shots as the barrel heats up. Some shooters get decent groups early, then frustration when things string wildly. Bedding and torque consistency are common complaints, and while some models shoot well, consistency across rifles just isn’t there. It’s a great concept, but one that often leaves you tuning or tweaking instead of hitting bullseyes. You expect a predator rifle to hold groups, not drift after three rounds. For a gun marketed at accuracy, it can feel like a gamble.
Savage B22 Precision
This one’s a heartbreaker for .22 LR fans. The aluminum chassis and target-style design scream accuracy. But once you run it, you realize it doesn’t always deliver on that promise. Flyers are too frequent, and some barrels seem to favor one random brand of ammo while hating everything else. The stock is rigid, sure—but the barrel isn’t always properly free-floated from the factory. It’s the kind of rifle that teases greatness but makes you chase it with every range trip. And if you expected it to be a budget trainer for your PRS rig, you might be disappointed more often than not.
Winchester XPR Compact
The XPR line made a lot of noise about being a modern, affordable alternative to more expensive bolt guns. The Compact version in particular feels like it was designed for ease of carry and quick handling, but not necessarily for precision. The trigger is serviceable, and the barrel is free-floated, but something about the action-to-stock fit tends to create inconsistent results. Some owners report solid sub-MOA groups, while others struggle to stay inside 2 inches at 100 yards. It’s one of those rifles where you’re constantly wondering if it’s you or the gun, and that’s not a great place to be.
Ruger SFAR
Ruger’s Small Frame Autoloading Rifle tried to bring .308-level power to an AR-15-sized package—and accuracy was one of its big selling points. In the real world, though, accuracy has been all over the map. Some rifles shoot minute-of-angle, while others toss shots unpredictably once the barrel gets warm. Add in ammo sensitivity and occasional over-gassing issues, and you’re left troubleshooting more than shooting. For a rifle that promised to bring “precision” to a lightweight .308 platform, the SFAR can make you feel like you need a different optic, a heavier buffer, and three types of match ammo just to shoot decently.
Tikka T3x Lite Roughtech
Tikka has a good reputation for accuracy, and some of that carries over here. But the Roughtech models sometimes deliver surprising disappointment, especially with lighter barrels. The recoil pad is solid, but the thin barrel contour heats quickly and doesn’t always cool evenly. And the factory stock—while textured and stiff—doesn’t always keep things bedded well under torque. Shooters have reported erratic cold-bore shots and wandering zero. If you expected the T3x to shoot like its heavier siblings, you might be chasing groups instead of printing them. It’s one of those rifles that looks serious but occasionally feels like it skipped the last step.
Diamondback DB10
You’ll see these .308 ARs at a lot of stores with attractive price tags and plenty of tactical flair. But when it comes to accuracy, the DB10 isn’t as consistent as you’d hope. It ships with a heavy barrel and decent furniture, but the fit and finish can be hit-or-miss. Some rifles shoot okay, others never group better than 2–3 inches at 100 yards—even with good ammo. Gas system tuning and buffer weights sometimes need adjusting just to get it to run smoothly. It’s marketed as a long-range .308 AR, but in practice, it often feels like you’re chasing your zero more than ringing steel.
Weatherby Vanguard S2 Youth
Vanguard rifles usually shoot well, but the Youth S2 model sometimes misses the mark—literally. The shorter barrel and lighter stock might make sense for smaller shooters, but it can throw off balance and harmonics. Add in a slightly stiffer trigger than expected and some factory bedding that doesn’t always settle right, and you’ve got a rifle that throws the occasional mystery flyer. It’s not terrible, but it’s inconsistent enough to make young or new shooters second-guess their skills. That’s a tough way to build confidence, especially when the rifle was supposed to be the accurate, forgiving option.
Remington 783 Heavy Barrel
Remington had high hopes for the 783 as an affordable precision bolt gun, especially the heavy barrel versions. But while the barrel is stout, the rest of the gun doesn’t always hold up. The trigger’s better than older Remington offerings, but the synthetic stock lacks rigidity and the bedding can shift under recoil. Accuracy starts decent, then degrades as the rifle warms. It’s one of those rifles that almost gets there but leaves you scratching your head when your second group opens up for no clear reason. For a “precision” model, it asks a lot of you to make up for its shortcomings.
Bergara B14 Hunter
Bergara has earned a solid following, but not every B14 Hunter hits the same. The Hunter model, with its lightweight stock and sporter barrel, can be a little too flexible in the wrong places. That factory synthetic stock doesn’t always maintain torque or consistency, especially after a season in varying temps. Group size can change from one range session to the next without a clear culprit. Many shooters end up swapping the stock to unlock the rifle’s potential, which is telling. You want it to shoot like the Ridge model, but the Hunter sometimes makes you work harder than expected for reliable accuracy.
Christensen Arms Ridgeline FFT
This rifle gets a lot of attention for being lightweight and carbon-wrapped, but not every Ridgeline FFT delivers tight groups out of the box. Some shooters rave about accuracy, others get discouraged fast. Reports of carbon barrels shifting point of impact as they heat up aren’t uncommon. And while the stock is stiff, the recoil impulse on such a light rifle doesn’t do you any favors when trying to stay steady. For the price, you expect predictable accuracy. But if your particular rifle doesn’t like your favorite ammo, you’re left spending more time at the reloading bench than the range.
Howa Hogue Rifle
The Howa action is respected for its smoothness and reliability, but the Hogue-stocked models can be a letdown. That soft rubber overmolding may feel nice in hand, but it allows for too much flex under pressure. Even with a free-floated barrel, the inconsistent bedding and compressible stock can throw off shot-to-shot performance. Some shooters report great results with certain ammo, but it rarely holds across conditions. It’s a rifle that teaches you to shoot around its quirks—and that’s not what you want when precision is the promise. If you’re serious about accuracy, this model might leave you searching for a stiffer setup.
Rossi R95 Triple Black
This lever-action .30-30 looks tactical and sells itself as a modern brush gun, but the accuracy side doesn’t always measure up. While the action runs fine and the finish is sharp, the barrel harmonics and sight mounting aren’t always dialed in. Shooters have reported groups opening up past 50 yards, even with decent ammo and optics. The handguard isn’t always stable either, which doesn’t help if you’re trying to shoot from a rest. It’s fun to carry and makes a statement, but when it’s time to get a clean shot past 75 yards, it often hands you more excuses than results.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
Calibers That Shouldn’t Even Be On the Shelf Anymore
Rifles That Shouldn’t Be Trusted Past 100 Yards
*This article was developed with AI-powered tools and has been carefully reviewed by our editors.
