Some gun regrets happen fast. You see the price, talk yourself out of it, come back later, and it is gone. Other regrets take years. A rifle that looked too plain turns into a hard-to-find favorite. A pistol everybody ignored gets discontinued. A shotgun that used to sit on used racks suddenly starts getting treated like something special.
That is the part buyers remember. It is not always about rare collector pieces or wild auction numbers. Sometimes it is about practical guns that were sitting right there when they were still affordable, available, and easy to justify. Then the market moved, production changed, or people finally figured out what they had missed.
Remington Model 700 Mountain Rifle
The Remington Model 700 Mountain Rifle is one of those hunting rifles buyers remember seeing and not quite appreciating enough. It was light, trim, and built for hunters who actually carried a rifle farther than a box blind.
Clean older examples now have a pull that many current lightweight rifles do not. The Mountain Rifle had classic lines, useful chamberings, and that familiar 700 action people already trusted. Plenty of hunters wish they had grabbed one when they were easier to find, especially in cartridges like .280 Remington, 7mm-08, or .270 Winchester.
Ruger No. 1
The Ruger No. 1 was always a little different, and that is exactly why buyers now regret passing on good ones. A single-shot falling-block rifle is not for everyone, but it has a feel and presence that stands apart from ordinary bolt guns.
For years, some shooters looked past it because it was slower, heavier, and more traditional than the practical rifles around it. Now the same traits make it more desirable. Nice No. 1 rifles in interesting chamberings have become the kind of guns people wish they had bought before they started feeling like special finds instead of regular catalog items.
Smith & Wesson Model 39
The Smith & Wesson Model 39 is easy to overlook if you only judge old pistols by modern capacity. But buyers who passed on them years ago often understand the regret now. It was slim, metal-framed, good-looking, and important to American double-action 9mm history.
A clean Model 39 has a feel that modern polymer pistols cannot copy. It carries nicely, points well, and represents a time when service pistols still had some craftsmanship to them. It is not the most efficient defensive handgun today, but that was never the whole point. Good ones got harder to ignore.
Winchester Model 70 Classic Stainless
The Winchester Model 70 Classic Stainless is the kind of rifle hunters wish they had bought when stainless hunting rifles still felt like serious long-term tools instead of just another SKU. It had controlled-round feed, a durable field finish, and enough traditional Model 70 feel to keep old-school hunters interested.
In rough weather, mountain country, or wet deer woods, it made a lot of sense. Some buyers passed because it was not the lightest or cheapest option. Now clean Classic Stainless rifles in useful chamberings make people pause, especially when they realize how much harder that exact combination is to replace.
Browning BSS
The Browning BSS is one of those shotguns that did not seem rare enough to panic over until it was too late. It was a solid Japanese-made side-by-side that gave hunters and upland shooters a serious double without stepping into fine-gun money.
Buyers who skipped them now often wish they had taken a closer look. The BSS was sturdy, tasteful, and built with a kind of practical quality that ages well. Good side-by-sides are not getting cheaper, and clean Browning examples carry more appeal now than they did when pump guns and semi-autos were soaking up the attention.
Colt Detective Special
The Colt Detective Special used to be a common little revolver in the minds of many buyers. It was a snubnose .38 with old police charm, six shots, and a frame size that gave it more hand-filling control than tiny five-shot revolvers.
Now people look at clean Detective Specials differently. The blue finish, compact shape, and Colt name all matter more than they used to. It is not the easiest revolver to replace with something modern, because modern snubs often feel cheaper or rougher by comparison. Buyers who walked past nice ones on used shelves probably remember it.
Marlin 1894C
The Marlin 1894C in .357 Magnum is exactly the kind of lever gun buyers wish they had grabbed before pistol-caliber carbines became hot again. It was handy, useful, soft-shooting, and cheaper to feed than many centerfire rifles.
A .357 lever gun makes sense for plinking, small-game work, defensive use in the right hands, and close-range deer hunting where legal and appropriate. That flexibility is why clean older 1894C rifles became so desirable. People who once thought they were neat but unnecessary now realize they filled a very practical gap.
Beretta 84 Cheetah
The Beretta 84 Cheetah is one of those pistols buyers underestimated because .380 ACP was not always taken seriously. But the pistol itself had style, quality, and shootability that made it far more interesting than most pocket .380s.
It is a metal-framed double-stack pistol with a smooth feel and classic Beretta lines. That combination hits differently now, especially as more shooters get tired of tiny defensive guns that are unpleasant to practice with. The 84 is not the most modern carry choice, but it is easy to understand why people wish they had bought one when prices felt friendlier.
Remington 7600
The Remington 7600 never made sense to every hunter, but in places where pump rifles were loved, it made all the sense in the world. It gave deer hunters fast follow-up shots, familiar shotgun-like handling, and real rifle cartridges.
For years, buyers outside pump-rifle country shrugged at them. Now clean 7600s, especially in classic deer cartridges, draw more interest than many people expected. They are not making many rifles quite like that anymore, and hunters who grew up around them know why they mattered. Passing on a nice one used to feel harmless. Now it can feel like a mistake.
Browning BLR
The Browning BLR has always lived in its own lane, and that lane looks better with time. It gives lever-action fans access to pointed-bullet cartridges and real reach while still carrying like a sporting rifle instead of a tactical project.
Buyers who dismissed it as odd sometimes regret that now. The BLR is not as traditional as a Model 94 and not as common as a bolt gun, but that is part of the appeal. It fills a role that not many rifles fill well. Clean older examples in good chamberings have a way of making practical hunters stop and think.
Smith & Wesson Model 5906
The Smith & Wesson Model 5906 spent a long time being treated like an old police trade-in. It was heavy, stainless, double-action, and not exactly fashionable once polymer striker guns took over.
That attitude has changed. Shooters now appreciate the 5906 for its durability, soft recoil, and old-school service-pistol feel. It is not light for carry, but on the range it feels steady and honest. A clean 5906 with good magazines is the kind of gun buyers once ignored because it seemed outdated. Now it looks like a lot of pistol for the money people used to pay.
Ruger Security-Six
The Ruger Security-Six is one of the revolvers buyers wish they had taken more seriously when they were cheaper. It was never as polished as some Smith & Wesson revolvers, but it was tough, useful, and built for real .357 Magnum work.
Its size was part of the appeal. It carried better than larger magnums but still gave shooters enough strength and control to handle steady use. When Ruger moved on to later designs, the Security-Six slowly gained more respect. People who passed on clean examples now realize it was one of Ruger’s best balanced revolvers.
Winchester 9422
The Winchester 9422 is a rimfire lever gun that people really should have bought when they had the chance. It was smooth, well-made, and far nicer than it needed to be for a .22 rifle. That is exactly why it aged so well.
A good 9422 makes cheap shooting feel special. It is useful for small game, fun for range work, and good enough to pass down without feeling like a toy. Buyers who once thought it was too expensive for a rimfire now get it. Quality .22 lever guns with that kind of feel do not sit around unnoticed anymore.
HK P7
The HK P7 is the kind of pistol buyers regret passing on because nothing else feels quite like it. The squeeze-cocker system, low bore axis, fixed barrel, and compact metal frame made it unusual when it was new and even more interesting now.
It was expensive, different, and not for everyone. That kept some buyers away. But today, that same weirdness is the reason people want one. The P7 is not just another old 9mm. It is a very specific piece of design history that shoots better than its size suggests. Nice examples are the ones people remember walking away from.
Savage 24
The Savage 24 combination gun used to feel like a humble utility piece. A rifle barrel over a shotgun barrel made sense for woods wandering, small game, farm use, and anyone who wanted one gun to cover several jobs.
For a long time, buyers treated them as odd but handy. Now clean examples have more charm because they represent a type of practical field gun that is not nearly as common as it once was. A Savage 24 is not perfect at any one thing, but it is useful in a way that sticks with people. That is why passing on a nice one stings later.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
