When you’re in the guiding business, you learn real quick which guns stay in the guest rack and which ones ride in your scabbard. The guns you lend out need to be affordable, easy to run, and forgiving of neglect. That doesn’t mean they’re what you’d stake your season—or your paycheck—on. Guides keep certain rifles and shotguns around because they’re “good enough,” not because they trust them with a long shot or a hard pack out. If a hunter bangs it up or drops it in the drink, no one cries. But when it’s your name on the line, you carry something else. You already know the difference. Here are the ones that get handed out—but never carried by the ones who know better.
Savage Axis
The Axis is cheap, and it usually works well enough at the range. That’s why it lives in guide shacks across the country. But its mushy trigger and hollow stock don’t exactly build confidence when shots get tricky. It’s fine for a buddy who forgot his rifle or a client who’s not picky.
Most guides who’ve used one wouldn’t bet a trophy tag on it. The bolt feels rough. The synthetic stock flexes if you tighten the sling hard. It’s light and affordable, but it doesn’t inspire much loyalty. Guides keep it around for emergencies, not because they like shooting it.
Remington 770
The 770 gets handed out because it’s easy to replace. And let’s be honest—it’s better than nothing. But you won’t find a seasoned guide who chooses one for his own hunts. The bolt throw is rough, the plastic magazine feels like a toy, and accuracy is hit or miss.
It shoots minute-of-deer most days, but that’s about it. Guides keep a 770 in the cabinet because it can take abuse and nobody’s heartbroken if it gets scratched. When it’s your tag on the line, though, there are way better tools to trust than this plastic-bodied gamble.
Mossberg 500 Turkey Thug
The 500 action is proven, but the Turkey Thug versions with short barrels and pistol grips often get dumped into the loaner pile. They’re clunky, awkward to swing, and uncomfortable to shoot with 3-inch magnums. Good enough for someone who forgot to pack a shotgun, not something you’d grab on purpose.
Guides will loan one out in a pinch because it works, not because it handles well. The controls are familiar, and it can take a beating, but nobody’s raving about how it patterns or balances. It gets the job done—and then goes back in the rack.
Ruger American Compact
It’s light, affordable, and easy for smaller-framed hunters to handle. But it’s also jumpy off the bench and not the easiest rifle to steady for longer shots. The short barrel and light weight are great for hauling, but they don’t do you any favors when accuracy matters.
Guides keep it around for youth hunters and folks who need something smaller, but they don’t usually carry one themselves. The trigger’s not bad, but the rifle feels more like a stepping stone than a trusted partner. It fills a role—but it rarely gets the prime spot in the safe.
Marlin X7
This rifle had its fans back when Marlin still made them under the old regime, but most guides saw it for what it was: a cheap bolt gun with a decent barrel and not much else. The plastic trigger guard, flexy stock, and inconsistent fitment didn’t inspire confidence.
It’s one of those rifles that you lend out with a shrug—“it’ll do.” Accuracy isn’t bad when it’s dialed in, but they’re finicky about ammo and don’t always hold zero well. It’s not a rifle you choose when the wind’s gusting and the elk are across a canyon.
Remington 710
The 710 was never respected by serious hunters, but it still lingers in closets and cabins because it technically works. Guides might loan one to a hunter who forgot his .30-06 ammo—because the 710 will probably feed it. That doesn’t mean it’s earned anyone’s trust.
The action is rough, and the plastic bedding system ages poorly. You’ll often find them with a no-name scope in cheap rings. It’ll punch paper at 100 yards, but the moment you stretch it, things start falling apart. It’s a last-resort kind of rifle, not a go-to choice.
CVA Hunter Single Shot
These single-shots are dirt cheap and handy for first-timers or loaners, especially in states with straight-wall cartridge rules. But they’re slow to reload, kick hard in the larger calibers, and aren’t ideal for follow-up shots. Guides use them because they’re simple—not because they’re optimal.
They’re fine for close-range deer hunts with someone who’s nervous around repeaters. But you won’t see a seasoned guide chasing elk or hogs with one unless everything else is broken. They’re better than nothing—and barely that if the hunter flinches after the first shot.
Mossberg Patriot
You’ll see these in lodge racks and outfitter trailers, usually with a low-end scope and a sling that’s fraying at the edges. The Patriot is inexpensive and often surprisingly accurate, but the long-term durability isn’t there. Guides hand them out when someone shows up unprepared.
The stock finish scuffs easy, the bolt throw can be inconsistent, and you never know how well the magazine’s going to behave. It’s not a terrible rifle, but it’s not the kind of gun you want to depend on when things get real. It’s built for price, not performance.
Rossi RS22
It’s a fun little rimfire and great for knocking over tin cans or popping a squirrel off a log. But guides don’t trust these for real work. They loan them to kids who’ve never shot before or to guests who want to plink without much recoil.
The action feels gritty, the trigger’s mediocre, and reliability gets shaky with bulk ammo. It’s okay as a warm-up tool, but it’s not what you bring along on a trapline or during small game season. Guides carry a 10/22 or a bolt gun. The Rossi stays in the box.
Remington 597
The 597 came out as an alternative to the 10/22, but it never really caught on with serious shooters. It’s finicky with ammo, hard to clean, and the factory magazines are a constant headache. Guides keep them around for loaners because they’re cheap—but rarely because they’re reliable.
If it runs, it’s decently accurate. But that “if” is doing a lot of work. You don’t want to deal with feeding issues when a guest is trying to knock down rabbits or chase raccoons. Most guides have one in the closet they don’t miss when it doesn’t come home.
Stevens 320
It’s a pump-action 12-gauge that’s usually priced low enough to be disposable. Guides might stash one in the corner of the truck or cabin, but they won’t brag about shooting it. The action feels sticky, the safety is oddly placed, and the recoil pad doesn’t do much.
It’ll cycle shells, but it doesn’t pattern particularly well, and the controls feel like they were designed by someone who’s never hunted birds in gloves. It’s a tool for when all your good shotguns are spoken for. Otherwise, it stays in the back until someone else needs a loaner.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
The worst deer rifles money can buy
Sidearms That Belong in the Safe — Not Your Belt
*This article was developed with AI-powered tools and has been carefully reviewed by our editors.
