The Mossberg 500 is one of the most common pump shotguns in America, which means everybody seems to have an opinion on it. Some people treat it like the budget king that can do no wrong. Others act like it is just a cheaper alternative to the Remington 870 and not worth a serious look. Both takes miss the point.
The Mossberg 500 became popular because it is simple, affordable, adaptable, and tough enough for the way regular people actually use shotguns. Mossberg says more than 12 million 500 Series shotguns have been sold, and the current 500 line still includes field, turkey, tactical, combo, and other versions. Standard 500 features include dual extractors, steel-to-steel lockup, twin action bars, an anti-jam elevator, and a top-mounted ambidextrous safety.
1. They Think the 500 Is Just a Cheap Shotgun
The Mossberg 500 has always been known for value, but value is not the same thing as junk. Some shooters hear “affordable” and assume the gun must be flimsy or disposable. That ignores why the 500 has lasted so long. A pump shotgun does not sell in those numbers for decades if it cannot do the work.
The 500 is affordable because Mossberg built it around simple, efficient design choices. It uses an aluminum-alloy receiver, dual action bars, dual extractors, and a straightforward pump-action system. It may not feel as polished as a high-end shotgun, but it does not need to. Its job is to be useful, durable, and accessible.
2. They Compare It to the 870 Too Simply
The Remington 870 and Mossberg 500 comparison will probably never die. Both are classic pump shotguns, and both have earned their place. But people oversimplify the debate by acting like one is automatically better in every way. That is not how it works.
The 870 has its steel receiver and long Wingmaster reputation. The 500 has its ambidextrous tang safety, dual extractors, lighter receiver, and strong barrel/accessory flexibility. A shooter who prefers one over the other may have good reasons. The mistake is pretending the 500 only exists because somebody could not afford an 870. The Mossberg has its own strengths.
3. They Forget It Is a Whole Series
A lot of people say “Mossberg 500” like they mean one exact shotgun. That is not accurate. The 500 is a series with field guns, turkey guns, tactical models, combo packages, different gauges, different barrel lengths, different stocks, and different capacities depending on configuration.
That matters when people argue about quality or usefulness. A 500 Field in 20 gauge is not the same tool as a 500 Tactical in 12 gauge. A combo field/deer package is not the same setup as a turkey gun. Before judging the platform, you need to know which 500 you are actually talking about.
4. They Think the Aluminum Receiver Is a Weakness
Some shooters look at the 500’s aluminum-alloy receiver and assume it must be weak compared with a steel-receiver shotgun. That is one of the more common misunderstandings. The receiver is not taking pressure the way the barrel and bolt lockup are. Mossberg’s standard features include positive steel-to-steel lockup, which is what matters for the action’s strength.
The aluminum receiver helps keep weight down and cost reasonable. That does not make the shotgun fragile. The 500 has been used hard by hunters, homeowners, and agencies for decades. A steel receiver may feel more substantial, but the 500’s receiver design has proven itself in real use.
5. They Underestimate the Top-Mounted Safety
The Mossberg 500’s tang-mounted safety is one of its best-known features, and some shooters still do not appreciate how useful it is. Mossberg specifically highlights the top-mounted safety for ambidextrous operation.
That matters if you are left-handed, teaching multiple shooters, or using the shotgun from field positions where hand placement changes. The safety is easy to see and easy to feel. The one catch is pistol-grip stocks. A traditional tang safety works beautifully with a normal stock, but it can be less convenient with a pistol grip because your thumb is no longer naturally on top of the receiver.
6. They Think Pump Guns Do Not Need Practice
The Mossberg 500 is simple, but simple does not mean effortless. A pump shotgun still has to be run hard and fully. Short-stroking the action can cause problems, and those problems often get blamed on the gun when the shooter is the real issue.
A 500 needs practice just like any other shotgun. You need to mount it properly, run the fore-end with authority, reload without fumbling, pattern your loads, and learn how the safety and action release feel without looking. The shotgun may be straightforward, but the shooter still has to do their part.
7. They Ignore the Dual Extractors
The Mossberg 500’s dual extractors are one of those features people mention quickly and then move past. They should not. Dual extractors give the gun two points of purchase on the shell rim during extraction, which is a nice reliability feature in a working pump shotgun.
That matters when a gun gets dirty, wet, cold, or fed cheap shells. Extraction is one of the places shotguns can get frustrating fast. The 500’s dual-extractor setup is part of why the design has such a strong reputation for practical reliability. It is not a flashy feature, but it does real work.
8. They Think All 500 Barrels Swap the Same Way
The 500 is known for barrel flexibility, but buyers still need to pay attention. Not every barrel fits every magazine-tube configuration. Six-shot and eight-shot setups can use different barrel attachment arrangements, and gauge matters too. A 12-gauge barrel is not going on a 20-gauge gun, obviously, but even within 12 gauge, configuration details matter.
That is important if you are buying a field/deer combo or planning to add a shorter defensive barrel later. The 500 is adaptable, but it is not magic. Check the exact model, magazine tube length, barrel lug position, and gauge before ordering parts. Shotgun parts compatibility can get annoying if you assume too much.
9. They Think the 500 and 590 Are the Same Gun
The 500 and 590 are closely related, but they are not identical. The 590 was developed for more military and tactical-style use, with differences around magazine tube design, barrel attachment, and service-focused features depending on the exact model. The 590A1 goes even further with heavier-duty features in certain configurations.
That does not mean the 500 is bad. It means the 500 and 590 fit different lanes. The 500 is one of the most versatile field and general-use pump shotguns around. The 590 family leans harder toward defensive and duty use. Buyers should choose based on role, not just the Mossberg name.
10. They Overlook the .410 and 20-Gauge Versions
The 12-gauge Mossberg 500 gets most of the attention, but the platform also exists in 20 gauge and .410 bore. Mossberg’s 500 Field page lists 12 gauge, 20 gauge, and .410 bore options.
That matters because not everyone needs or wants a 12 gauge. A 20-gauge 500 can be a great field gun for smaller-framed shooters, newer shooters, or hunters who do not want as much recoil. A .410 has a narrower role, but it can still be useful for certain small-game, pest, or youth-training purposes when handled responsibly. The 500 family is broader than many people remember.
11. They Think a Tactical 500 Is Automatically Better
A shorter barrel, heat shield, pistol grip, collapsible stock, shell holder, and rails may look serious, but that does not automatically make a Mossberg 500 better. A defensive shotgun should be set up around control, reliability, light use, sling needs, and the shooter’s ability to run it well.
Some tactical accessories help. A quality light can be important for a home-defense shotgun. A good sling can matter. Better sights may help with slugs or buckshot accountability. But too many add-ons can make the shotgun heavier, slower, and more awkward. A plain 500 with the right barrel, light, and stock may be more useful than one covered in cheap accessories.
12. They Do Not Pattern Their Loads
This is not only a Mossberg issue, but it shows up constantly with 500 owners. People buy a shotgun, load it with buckshot, and assume the pattern will behave like a movie spread. That is not how shotguns work. At home-defense distances, buckshot can stay much tighter than expected. At longer ranges, it can open unpredictably depending on the load and barrel.
A Mossberg 500 owner needs to pattern the exact load they plan to use. Birdshot, buckshot, slugs, turkey loads, and field loads all behave differently. Chokes matter. Barrel length matters. Ammunition matters. The gun does not tell you what it does on paper unless you actually shoot it on paper.
13. They Assume It Is Maintenance-Free
The 500 is reliable, but it still needs basic care. Dirt, fouling, rust, worn magazine springs, damaged shell stops, and loose parts can cause problems. Pump guns are tolerant, not invincible.
The good news is that the 500 is not hard to maintain. Its design is simple, parts support is strong, and most routine cleaning is manageable for regular owners. Keep it clean enough, inspect it occasionally, and replace worn parts when needed. A shotgun that lives in a closet for ten years without attention should not be expected to run like it was cared for.
14. They Miss How Adaptable It Really Is
The Mossberg 500’s greatest strength may be adaptability. Mossberg calls the 500 one of the most versatile shotgun platforms available, and that is not empty talk. Field barrels, deer barrels, turkey setups, youth stocks, defensive barrels, different gauges, different sights, and different stock options all give the platform a lot of range.
That makes it a smart shotgun for people who need one gun to cover several jobs. A 500 combo package can handle deer season and bird season with barrel changes. A field gun can be adapted for turkey. A defensive setup can be kept simple and practical. The 500’s flexibility is a major reason it has stayed popular.
15. They Forget Why the 500 Became Popular
The Mossberg 500 became popular because it gave regular people a reliable, affordable, easy-to-use pump shotgun that could be adapted to almost any normal shotgun job. Mossberg says the first Model 500 was produced in August 1962 and became legendary for reliability and durability, eventually leading to multiple variants.
That is the part shooters still misunderstand. The 500 does not have to be the fanciest shotgun in the rack. It does not have to beat every pump gun in every category. It became important because it works, costs less than many competitors, fits many roles, and keeps showing up when people need a shotgun that can take normal abuse. That is not glamorous, but it is exactly how a working gun earns respect.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
