Photo credit: 404 Tactical/Youtube
Most gun regrets aren’t about what you bought. They’re about what you let go of because you “needed to fund something else,” or you figured you could replace it later. Then later shows up, and the same gun is either discontinued, doubled in price, or you realize it did a job none of your new stuff does quite as well.
I’m not saying never sell a firearm. Safes get full, priorities change, and sometimes a gun just doesn’t fit your hands or your life. But there are certain models that have a way of haunting you after they’re gone—because they were more useful than you gave them credit for, or because they’ve got a feel you can’t buy back once you’ve moved on.
1. Ruger 10/22 Carbine
It’s the “boring” .22 that ends up being the most shot gun in the safe. A basic 10/22 will run dirty, eat bulk ammo better than it has any right to, and it points naturally for squirrels, rabbits, and tin cans behind the barn.
Folks dump them to “upgrade” into something fancier, or because they’ve got three .22s already. Then a kid needs a first rifle, or you want a cheap trainer that mirrors your hunting rifle habits, and you realize you sold the one gun that was always ready to go.
2. Remington 870 Wingmaster
There’s a slickness to a good Wingmaster that the newer budget pump guns don’t always have. The action feels like it’s on oiled rails, and the gun carries easy in the crook of your arm when you’re walking fencerows.
The regret usually hits after you’ve handled a few newer shotguns and none of them cycle quite the same. The old ones also tend to wear honest bluing and walnut, and that stuff just doesn’t come back once you trade it off for a “tactical” project you stop caring about in six months.
3. Marlin Model 336 (JM-stamped)
If you’ve hunted thick timber, you already get it. A 336 in .30-30 carries like a walking stick, comes up fast, and puts a deer down inside sane distances without drama. It’s not a long-range rifle and it doesn’t need to be.
The older JM-marked guns especially have a following for a reason. Once you sell a good one, replacing it can turn into a scavenger hunt at gun shows and pawn shops, and you’ll still wonder if the next one will shoot as well as the one you let go.
4. Glock 19 (Gen 3 or Gen 5)
The Glock 19 is the plain ham sandwich of pistols. Not exciting. Not romantic. Just useful. It’s the handgun you can carry, train with, feed easily, find holsters for everywhere, and hand to a new shooter without worrying about weird controls.
The reason it stings when it’s gone is simple: it’s a baseline. When you’re rotating through the “next big thing,” the G19 is the one you measure everything against, and it’s frustrating to realize you traded away the one pistol that always worked and always had support.
5. Smith & Wesson Model 10
A Model 10 isn’t fancy, and that’s kind of the point. It’s a K-frame .38 that shoots where you look, carries well in a belt holster, and doesn’t beat you up at the range. It also teaches good trigger control without excuses.
These get sold because they’re “just an old revolver.” Then you go shopping for a clean one and find out everyone else figured out they’re the perfect working revolver, and the nice examples don’t sit long.
6. Ruger GP100 (4-inch)
The GP100 is what you buy when you’re tired of babying guns. It’s built like a fence post, handles .357 Mag without feeling like it’s rattling itself apart, and it’ll digest a steady diet of midrange loads forever.
Sell one and you’ll miss it the next time you want a woods sidearm that doesn’t care about mud, rain, or neglect. Semi-autos are great, but a stout revolver that always goes bang has a way of earning its keep in hunting camp.
7. Colt Python (older production)
I get why folks sell Pythons. They’re valuable, and money is money. But that smooth Colt action and the way a good Python locks up is hard to explain until you’ve shot one beside other revolvers.
Once it’s gone, the replacement question gets ugly fast. You’re either paying a premium for another older one, or you’re convincing yourself that something else is “close enough,” and you’ll know it isn’t every time you pick it up.
8. Browning Hi-Power
There are thinner, lighter carry guns. There are higher-capacity guns. Still, a Hi-Power sits in the hand like it was designed by someone who actually carried a pistol, not just drew it on a whiteboard.
They get sold because they’re all-steel and “dated.” Then you handle one again, feel how it points, and you remember why so many serious people trusted them for so long. That one hurts.
9. SIG Sauer P226
The P226 is not a small gun, and it’s not cheap to feed if you’re shooting a lot of premium ammo. But it’s one of those pistols that makes average shooters look better on the range because the trigger and balance just cooperate.
When you sell it, you notice the gap later—usually after you’ve tried a couple “value” pistols that work fine but don’t inspire confidence the same way. The P226 is a steady tool, and steady tools are easy to undervalue until they’re missing.
10. CZ 75B
The CZ 75B is one of the best-shooting “regular guy” pistols ever made. It soaks up recoil, tracks flat, and tends to run and run. The ergonomics fit a lot of hands, and the accuracy is usually better than its price tag suggests.
It’s often sold to fund something newer, smaller, or more “modern.” Then you realize you sold the pistol you actually shot well, and you can’t buy skill at the gun counter. Ask me how I know.
11. Ruger Mark II (or Mark IV)
A Ruger Mark-series pistol is a range workhorse and a small-game hammer. The triggers can be excellent, they’re naturally accurate, and they’ll make you want to shoot more—which is the whole point of a .22 handgun.
Older Mark IIs, especially, have a reputation for being tanks. Folks let them go because they want optics-ready features or a lighter feel, and then they realize the old Ruger never cared what ammo you fed it and always hit what you aimed at.
12. Winchester Model 70 (pre-64 or classic controlled-round feed)
There’s a reason the Model 70 has the nickname it does. A good one feeds smoothly, carries right in the hands, and feels like a real rifle when you’re climbing ridges with a sling digging into your shoulder.
These get sold when somebody moves to a cheaper synthetic rifle, or they decide they’re going all-in on one cartridge and need cash. Later, you want a “forever” bolt gun again, and you find out the good Model 70s don’t come cheap or easy.
13. Remington Model 700 (older production)
The 700 is common enough that people assume it’s always replaceable. But the older ones with good triggers and straight stocks have a feel that a lot of newer rifles don’t match, especially once you’ve carried one for years.
It’s also the bolt gun with the most support in the world—stocks, bases, rings, triggers, smiths who know them. Sell a solid 700 and you might end up with a rifle that shoots fine, but doesn’t have the same ecosystem behind it when you want to tweak something.
14. Savage Model 99
The 99 is one of those rifles you don’t “need” until you do. It carries like a lever gun, but it handles cartridges that make sense for deer and black bear, and it has a classic look without being delicate.
People sell them because they inherited it and don’t feel attached, or because it isn’t a scope-friendly tactical platform. Then the history catches up, and you realize you let a piece of American hunting culture walk out the door.
15. Ruger No. 1
Single-shots aren’t for everybody, and I won’t pretend they are. But the Ruger No. 1 has a way of making you slow down and shoot like you mean it. The rifle is compact for its barrel length, balances beautifully, and looks right in camp.
When one leaves your safe, it’s usually because it’s “impractical.” Then you’re sitting on a stand watching a cutover, wishing you still had that classy rifle that made every shot feel like a deliberate choice instead of a spray-and-pray option.
16. Henry Repeating Arms Golden Boy
This is one of those guns that gets dismissed as a “nice-to-have” until you see who it actually gets shot by. Everybody. Kids, new shooters, old-timers, and the guy who swears he only likes centerfire rifles. The Golden Boy just invites range time.
Sell it and you’ll miss the simple joy of a smooth lever .22 that makes a slow afternoon feel like a holiday. Not every gun has to be a defensive tool or a hunting hammer. Some are for keeping the spark lit.
17. Mossberg 500 (field/security combo)
The Mossberg 500 isn’t glamorous, and the finish on some of them looks like it was applied during a lunch break. Still, they run. They take abuse. And if you’ve got one set up for both birds and home use, it covers a lot of ground for not much money.
These get sold because they’re “cheap.” Then you need a spare shotgun for a buddy, a camp gun you don’t worry over, or a backup for turkey season, and you realize the humble 500 was doing more work than you gave it credit for.
18. Benelli Super Black Eagle (SBE)
If you’ve spent enough cold mornings in a duck blind, you start valuing a shotgun that cycles when everything is wet, gritty, and half-frozen. The SBE earned its reputation the hard way, and plenty of them have lived rough lives and kept running.
They’re pricey, which is why they get sold during tight times. Then you’re back to a shotgun that’s pickier about loads or needs more cleaning, and you remember exactly what you had. Reliability feels expensive until you don’t have it.
19. Springfield Armory M1A (Standard)
The M1A is not light, not cheap, and not the most practical rifle if you’re trying to do everything with one platform. But it has a feel—steel, wood, and that old-school action—that modern rifles just don’t replicate.
Sell it and you’ll miss it the next time you’re on the range and want to shoot something with soul. Also, good magazines and parts aren’t impossible, but they’re not as casual as AR stuff. When you have a sorted M1A, you tend to forget the work it took to get it there.
20. Colt AR-15 (LE6920)
This one isn’t about being the fanciest AR. It’s about having a known-quality baseline rifle that just works, takes standard parts, and holds its value in the real world, not just in internet arguments.
The LE6920 is the kind of rifle you sell because you think you’ll “build something better.” Sometimes you do. A lot of times you build a rifle that’s fine, but it never feels as settled and trustworthy as the Colt did right out of the box.
If you’re staring at the safe thinking about what to move down the road, I’d at least slow down on the guns that actually get used and the ones you can’t easily replace with an equivalent. Sell duplicates, sell mistakes, sell safe-queens you don’t care about. But the rifles and handguns that quietly solve problems year after year? Those are the ones you end up chasing later.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
