Photo credit: AI-generated image created using ChatGPT. Illustrative only
If you’ve ever put in for a hard-to-draw elk permit year after year, you already know the feeling: you’re doing it the right way, playing by the rules, and hoping the odds finally break your direction. In Montana’s Hunting District 380, those odds are brutal—under 1% in 2023. And that’s why this case out of the Elkhorn Mountains hits like a punch to the gut.
Based on details laid out in the original post, two East Helena residents bypassed the permit system entirely and killed three six-point bull elk during archery season—using rifles—along with several deer. One of the main defendants later appeared for sentencing over Zoom from Montana State Prison, where he’s serving time on an unrelated sexual assault conviction.
A permit unit with less than a 1% chance—ignored completely
Hunting District 380 isn’t just “tough to draw.” It’s one of those units that makes a guy plan years ahead, save vacation days, and keep applying even when he’s convinced he’ll never see his name come up. Court records cited in the report put the 2023 draw success rate at 0.94% for a bull elk permit.
That number matters because it’s the whole point of the permit system: limited opportunity, managed harvest, and a fair shake for everyone willing to wait their turn. In this case, three mature six-point bulls were taken without a legal permit in play, which means three animals removed from a tightly controlled unit and three chances erased from the pool.
The case started with a landowner hearing shots in the dark
Poaching cases don’t usually unravel because someone confesses. They unravel because a landowner is paying attention, hears something that doesn’t fit, and makes the call. Here, a landowner reported hearing gunshots on his property at night and then turning on the lights to investigate.
One of the whitetail bucks involved was reportedly left right where it fell after that incident. The landowner contacted Montana Fish, Wildlife, and Parks, and that call kicked off a year-long investigation that eventually tied the activity to Tylor Castona and Alisha Byrd.
Rifles during archery season, spotlighting, and tag games
According to court documents summarized in the source material, the violations weren’t a single bad decision—it was a string of them. The two defendants illegally shot three bull elk with rifles during archery season in the Elkhorn Mountains. They also took three whitetail bucks.
Wardens uncovered additional violations that included hunting without valid licenses, using artificial light to locate and shoot deer at night, and transferring tags between hunters. That last part is worth slowing down on, because “tag swapping” and “loaning a tag” is one of those things that some folks still try to talk themselves into. It doesn’t work that way, and cases like this show exactly where it ends up.
Wardens called it a trophy-targeting poaching case
The lead investigator, game warden Troy Hinck, didn’t mince words. “It’s just a very flagrant poaching case that demonstrates they will use any means to take the most vulnerable animals and that they are targeting our largest trophies,” he told reporters.
He also pointed out the real-world value of what was stolen. If a hunter were paying for a private outfitted opportunity, Hinck estimated each of those bulls could represent about a $10,000 opportunity. Whether a person supports outfitted hunts or not, the point stands: these weren’t accidental spikes or “I thought it was a cow.” These were mature bulls in a unit people wait years to hunt.
Sentencing: jail time, restitution, and long privilege losses
By December 2024, Castona, 40, was facing 16 misdemeanor poaching charges tied to over-limit hunting, illegal possession of game animals, and violations involving licenses and equipment. His sentencing happened June 25, and he joined the hearing via Zoom from Montana State Prison, where he is currently incarcerated for sexual assault.
Lewis and Clark County District Court Judge Kathy Seely sentenced Castona to six months in jail, ordered $12,650 in restitution, and handed down a 30-year loss of hunting, fishing, and trapping privileges. In the hunting world, that last part is a lifetime-sized penalty. A lot of guys won’t even be physically able to pack an elk out 30 years from now.
Byrd pleaded guilty in April to four misdemeanor poaching charges and one felony count of tampering with a witness or information, with six other misdemeanor charges dismissed as part of the plea deal. She was sentenced June 13 by Judge Michael McMahon to six months in jail, with all but 30 days suspended, plus a $50 fine and $1,100 restitution. Her hunting, fishing, and trapping privileges were revoked for 10 years.
The case also reached beyond the two main defendants. Castona’s nephew, Tracer Castona, pleaded guilty to two misdemeanor charges for helping recover one of the bull elk.
What this looks like on the ground for honest hunters and landowners
This is the part that doesn’t show up on a charging document. When someone shoots deer at night and leaves one where it falls, it isn’t just “a game violation”—it’s a safety problem for the landowner who hears shots in the dark and doesn’t know where they’re coming from or what direction they’re headed. That’s how rural people end up making hard decisions: lights on, phone in hand, trying to gather enough information to report it without escalating it.
For the law-abiding hunters, the damage is just as real even if it’s harder to measure. Three mature bulls removed from a coveted unit is three fewer chances for someone who drew a tag fair and square—or the guy who’s been applying for a decade and still hasn’t sniffed 1% luck. And when people get caught swapping tags, hunting without licenses, or bending seasons, it gives ammunition to every anti-hunting argument that claims hunters can’t regulate themselves.
The clean takeaway is the old one: if you own ground, document what you can and make the call when something feels off. And if you hunt—especially in permit units—treat tags, seasons, and weapon restrictions like they’re part of your rifle and pack. Because the folks willing to cheat aren’t just stealing animals. They’re stealing opportunity from everyone doing it right.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
