Some guns just don’t make sense to buy brand new. Whether it’s because of inflated price tags, better older versions, or the fact that they drop in value the second you walk out the door, you’re better off going used. This list isn’t about trashing these guns—it’s about getting more for your money without sacrificing performance.
Springfield M1A
The M1A is a solid rifle, but the new ones cost a small fortune. Older, well-maintained models perform just as well and can be found for way less. Plus, quality on some newer ones has been hit or miss. If you want one, check the used racks first. It’s one of those guns where secondhand often means better value.
Remington 870 (Recent Production)
The 870 used to be rock-solid, but newer versions haven’t lived up to that reputation. Cost-cutting measures have led to rough actions, poor finishes, and loose tolerances. If you want an 870 that runs like it should, grab one made before the 2000s. They’re smoother and built with better parts.
Colt Python (Modern Reissue)
The reissued Python looks sharp, but it doesn’t carry the same soul or collector appeal as the originals. And it’s expensive—like “you could buy two used revolvers” expensive. A vintage Python holds value better and still shoots like a dream. If you’re after that name, go old.
Desert Eagle
New Desert Eagles are flashy and fun, but also expensive shelf queens for most folks. There’s a healthy used market, and unless you’re chasing a limited edition finish, there’s no reason to pay full price. Lightly used ones shoot the same and save you hundreds.
FN SCAR 17S
It’s a beast of a rifle with a heavy price tag. Unless you’re in love with the newest tan finish or some minor upgrade, a gently used SCAR will give you the same performance. They’re durable rifles that don’t wear fast—no sense in buying one fresh off the line.
HK USP
The USP is overbuilt and dependable, but the used market is full of police trade-ins and privately owned models in excellent condition. New ones are pricey, and let’s face it—the design hasn’t changed in years. You won’t miss anything by going pre-owned.
Benelli M4
This shotgun is a favorite for a reason, but at full retail, it stings. Used models are often barely shot—folks buy them, realize they’re heavy for home defense, and list them. It’s easy to shave a few hundred off and still get a shotgun that’ll outlast you.
Marlin 336 (Post-Remington)
Marlin under Remington had some serious quality issues. Rough machining, misaligned sights, and poor fit plagued the early runs. If you want a 336, aim for a pre-2008 model or wait for the new Ruger-made ones to show up used. Either way, skip the mid-Remington years.
SIG Sauer P226 Legion
It’s a great pistol—no doubt. But the Legion tax is real. A used P226 will shoot just as well and cost a whole lot less. The fancy coating and Legion branding don’t improve function. If you want performance without the price, skip buying it new.
Ruger Mini-14
New Mini-14s have crept up in price without major improvements. The used market is full of older stainless models that still shoot great. If you’re not picky about tactical stocks or rails, a used Ranch Rifle will scratch the itch and save you cash.
Browning Hi-Power (Modern Clones)
There’s a wave of new Hi-Power clones on the market, but they don’t always match the fit and finish of the originals. Classic Browning-made versions often cost less and hold their value better. If you want that legendary feel, skip the modern re-creations and hunt down a well-kept original.
Kimber 1911s
They look good and shoot fine, but they’re not cheap. And many used ones pop up after only a few hundred rounds. Kimber fans often rotate models, so you can score a barely-used version for hundreds less. New just doesn’t buy you anything special here.
Mossberg 500 Turkey or Tactical Models
Mossberg 500s are workhorses, but the “specialized” models come with a markup. Folks buy them for a season, then trade them in. You’ll find used turkey or home defense versions for a steal—and they’ll work just as well as new. It’s one of the easiest buys to make used.
CZ 75 SP-01
CZ builds them right, but the newer SP-01s cost more than they used to. And because they’re popular with competition shooters, plenty of low-mileage models hit the used market. Buying used means more room in your budget for mags and upgrades.
*This article was developed with AI-powered tools and has been carefully reviewed by our editors.
