Not every bad handgun is outright broken. A lot of them are worse than that. They are disappointing in ways that take a little time to show up. Some sell on gimmicks. Some lean on brand recognition. Some get defended because they are unusual, not because they are especially good. New buyers get pulled in by the pitch, while more experienced shooters usually take one look and start spotting the compromises.
That is really what this comes down to. A bad handgun does not have to be unsafe or impossible to fire. It only has to make less sense than the alternatives sitting right next to it. If a pistol is awkward, too specialized, too gimmicky, overpriced for what it offers, or flat-out frustrating to use, it earns a place on a list like this. Here are 15 handguns that are among the worst buys on the market right now.
Taurus Judge
The Judge still gets attention because the whole idea sounds clever at the counter. A revolver that chambers both .410 shotshells and .45 Colt makes some buyers feel like they are getting more versatility than a regular handgun can offer. That pitch has worked for years, especially on people who are more impressed by novelty than by clean, practical performance.
The problem is that the gun never really shines in a focused role. It is bulky, awkward, and built around compromises that show up fast once you start shooting it seriously. The .410 side is overhyped, and the .45 Colt side usually leaves buyers wondering why they did not just buy a better revolver in the first place. It sells a concept harder than it delivers results.
Taurus Public Defender Poly
The Public Defender Poly tries to make the Judge formula look more manageable by trimming weight and shrinking the package a bit. That makes it easy for buyers to think they are getting a smarter, handier version of the same idea. In the store, it can feel like a more practical take on a gun that was already pitched as a do-it-all answer.
It still runs into the same wall. Lighter weight does not fix the basic problem that the platform is more compromise than capability. You are still buying a bulky revolver with a confused purpose and a shooting experience that rarely lives up to the sales pitch. It may be easier to carry than a larger Judge, but that does not make it a good handgun buy.
Taurus Raging Judge
The Raging Judge takes an already questionable concept and turns it into something even more excessive. Bigger frame, more bulk, more swagger, and even more of the same “look what this thing can chamber” energy make it easy to understand why emotional buyers get drawn to it. It feels dramatic, and drama sells.
What it does not feel like is a smart purchase for most people. The size is ridiculous for a handgun with such a compromised role, and the whole experience ends up leaning heavily on spectacle. This is the kind of revolver people buy because it sounds wild and looks impressive, not because it meaningfully outperforms simpler and better guns. That is a terrible reason to spend real money.
Smith & Wesson Governor
The Governor is what happens when a respected brand takes a bad idea and gives it a cleaner badge. Some buyers see Smith & Wesson on the side and assume the whole .410 revolver concept must make more sense here. That brand confidence helps this gun get more credibility than the basic idea deserves.
It still suffers from the same underlying issue as the Judge family. It is big, compromise-heavy, and easier to explain than to justify. Buyers talk themselves into the different chambering options, but the actual use case stays muddy. For the price, there are too many genuinely capable handguns out there to spend your money on something that is mostly built around being different.
Bond Arms Rowdy
The Rowdy looks tough, compact, and unusual enough to grab buyers immediately. Heavy steel construction and that little two-shot pocket-cannon image make it feel like a serious piece of hardware in a tiny package. A lot of people get sold right there, long before they start asking what the thing is actually good at.
Then they shoot it and the shine wears off fast. Two-shot derringers are already asking a lot from the buyer, and this one brings all the usual tradeoffs with very little practical payoff. It is harsh, limited, and far less useful than a decent compact revolver or semiauto. It has attitude, sure, but attitude is not enough to make a handgun worth owning.
Bond Arms Snake Slayer
The Snake Slayer is one of those handguns people buy because it feels solid and different in the hand. It has that rugged little backup-gun vibe, and Bond Arms does a good job making these derringers feel overbuilt and memorable. For some buyers, that alone is enough to close the deal.
That still does not make it a good handgun. The shooting experience is narrow, the capacity is laughably low, and the practical value is nowhere near what the styling suggests. A lot of people buy these because they admire the design and craftsmanship, which is fair. They just should not confuse that admiration with actual performance. As a real-world handgun purchase, this is a weak move.
North American Arms Pug
The Pug is easy to want because it is tiny enough to amaze people. That is the entire trap. Buyers see something that small and instantly start imagining it as the ultimate hideout gun, the one that can live anywhere and still count as being armed. Novelty does a lot of work for these mini revolvers.
Once you try to use one like a serious handgun, the flaws become obvious. Tiny grip, tiny sights, tiny practical payoff. These guns are interesting little mechanical pieces, but they are miserable substitutes for almost any normal defensive or range handgun. A lot of people buy them because they are cool to own. That is not the same as them being good.
North American Arms Earl
The Earl leans even harder into novelty by adding old-timey styling to an already compromised mini-revolver platform. That gives it even more charm at the counter, especially for buyers who like weird little guns with some personality. It looks like something you buy because it will start conversations, and that is exactly what many people do.
As a handgun you plan to actually use, it makes even less sense. The platform is already limited, and dressing it up does not change that. If anything, it pushes the gun even farther into novelty territory. Buyers who want fun conversation pieces may enjoy owning one. Buyers who care about shootability, usefulness, or real value should keep their wallet closed.
Walther P22
The P22 keeps fooling people because it looks like the perfect fun little rimfire. It is compact, modern-looking, and priced in a way that makes buyers think they are getting easy, low-cost range fun without much risk. In the display case, it feels like a safe little purchase.
Then the reputation shows up. Too many shooters have found the P22 to be picky, inconsistent, or more trouble than it should be for a simple .22 pistol. Rimfires already require some patience, but this one has burned enough owners that it keeps landing on lists like this. There are better .22 handguns out there, and buying a P22 often feels like choosing the familiar name over the better option.
KelTec PMR-30
The PMR-30 gets bought because the specs sound exciting. Thirty rounds of .22 Magnum in a lightweight pistol is exactly the kind of thing that makes buyers feel like they found something clever and different. It sounds fun, and to be fair, it can be. That is a big part of why people keep talking themselves into one.
The downside is that “interesting” and “great” are not the same thing. The PMR-30 has long had the kind of reputation that comes with caveats, especially when people start talking about ammo preferences and overall consistency. A gun like this survives on concept and grin factor more than on being a truly dependable, satisfying handgun. That puts it in bad-buy territory for a lot of people.
Magnum Research Desert Eagle Mark XIX
The Desert Eagle is iconic, and that is exactly why it belongs here. People do not buy it because it is the smartest handgun for almost any task. They buy it because it is huge, recognizable, and impossible to ignore. It feels legendary in the hand, and that emotional pull is powerful enough to override a lot of common sense.
Once the glamour fades, you are left with an oversized, expensive-to-feed, awkward handgun that spends more time being admired than being used. It is not junk. It is worse than junk in one specific way: it convinces people to pay serious money for a handgun whose main strength is the reaction it gets. That is a terrible value proposition.
Chiappa Rhino 60DS
The Rhino sells itself on being different in a way that makes buyers feel smart. Low bore axis, futuristic shape, and the whole “rethought revolver” pitch give it instant appeal for people who want something beyond the usual wheelgun formulas. In theory, it sounds like one of those rare designs that really solved an old problem.
In practice, it is far more divisive than the concept suggests. Some shooters genuinely like them, but plenty of others find the trigger, controls, and overall handling less satisfying than expected. The price only makes that sting more. This is one of those handguns that keeps getting bought for its idea, while the ownership experience often ends up much more mixed.
KelTec PLR16
The PLR16 is one of those handguns that exists mainly to make people say “that’s wild.” A 5.56 handgun with that kind of layout is always going to get attention, and KelTec has built a whole reputation around producing firearms that appeal to buyers who want something unconventional. That absolutely includes this one.
The issue is that unconventional does not equal worthwhile. It is loud, awkward, specialized, and not especially pleasant unless you are specifically chasing the weirdness. As a practical handgun, it makes very little sense. As a compact rifle substitute, it is still a compromise. That leaves it stuck in a lane where the novelty is doing almost all the work.
Bond Arms Rowdy XL
The Rowdy XL tries to look like the more usable version of the standard Rowdy, and that is how a lot of buyers justify it. Slightly larger grip, a little more shootability, and the same tough little derringer identity make it easy to believe this one fixes what the smaller model lacked. That is a nice story.
It still leaves you with a heavy, low-capacity derringer that asks you to accept all the same platform limitations. The extra size does not magically turn it into a smart defensive choice or a satisfying range companion. It just gives buyers a slightly improved version of a weak concept. That is not enough to save it from being one of the worst handgun buys around.
North American Arms Black Widow
The Black Widow is probably one of the easier mini revolvers to defend because it at least tries to be a little more usable than the tiniest NAA offerings. Better sights and a somewhat friendlier overall setup make buyers think they are getting the practical version of the mini-revolver idea. That helps it survive criticism a little better.
But it still lives inside the same tiny-gun box. The platform remains limited, difficult to shoot well compared to normal handguns, and largely appealing because of concealability and novelty rather than performance. Some people love these for what they are, and that is fine. But if we are talking about the worst handgun buys on the market right now, this whole family still earns its place.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
