Photo credit: dotshock/Shutterstock.com
The Avid Outdoorsman is reader-supported. If you buy through links in this article, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
The best deer rifle for straight wall states, for most hunters reading this mid-season, is a .350 Legend bolt gun — and the Ruger American Gen II is the one we’d put money on. It’s light, it has a factory muzzle brake and an adjustable stock, ammo is everywhere, and it kills deer dead inside 200 yards. Hunt thick timber? The .45-70 and .360 Buckhammer levers below do that job better.
First, the rules, because a lot of what’s online about them is a year or two stale. We checked all six states against their own current regulations today, 21 October 2026. Everything on the guns themselves is based on manufacturer specs, published ballistics and owner feedback, not hands-on testing.
The 2026 rules, state by state
This is the part competing articles get wrong. Read your own state’s current regulations before you buy anything — these summaries are a starting point, not legal advice.
Ohio — a true straight-wall state. Ohio is the one that actually means it. Ohio Administrative Code 1501:31-15-11, effective 6 July 2026, requires a rifle “chambered for a straight-walled cartridge with a minimum caliber of .357 to a maximum caliber of .515.” Necked-down cartridges are flatly unlawful, and gun season limits you to three rounds in magazine and chamber combined. The 2026-27 regulations booklet, effective 1 September 2026, states the range as .357 to .50 and names the .350 Legend as qualifying. Gun season is 30 November to 6 December 2026.
Michigan — the Limited Firearms Deer Zone is gone. This is the change most articles haven’t caught up with. Michigan’s 2026 Deer Hunting Regulations Summary says plainly: “The limited firearms deer zone has been eliminated,” and “Beginning Sept. 12, 2026, hunters can use all legal firearms across the Lower Peninsula.” Straight-walls are still perfectly legal there, just no longer required south of the old rifle line. One honest warning: the DNR’s own equipment-regulations subpage still listed the old zone restrictions (.35 caliber minimum, straight-walled, 1.16” to 1.80” case) when we looked today. Go by the 2026 summary, and call the DNR if you’re unsure.
Indiana — a bullet-diameter test, and a wide one. Indiana never used a straight-wall list, and it’s now looser than most hunters realize. The DNR’s current deer hunting equipment page allows “centerfire rifles with a bullet diameter of at least .219 inches or 5.56 mm,” with no case-length limit, on public and private land during youth, firearms and deer reduction zone seasons. FMJ bullets are illegal, and you may carry no more than ten of each cartridge type. That came from Senate Bill 280, signed as Public Law 76 in April 2025 and applying to seasons after 30 June 2025. The older rule text (312 IAC 9-3-3) still reads .357 inch with a 1.16” to 1.8” case; the statute and the DNR’s current page supersede it. Firearms season is 14-29 November 2026.
Iowa — caliber plus energy. Iowa’s test is about the bullet, not the shape of the case: “straight-wall and ‘necked-down’ cartridge rifles shooting an expanding type bullet of at least .350 inches,” within a caliber range of .350 to .500, “with at least 500 foot pounds of muzzle energy.” That applies to the youth/disabled and shotgun 1 and 2 seasons. The guide names .350 Legend, .45-70 Gov’t and .500 S&W as examples and says the list isn’t complete — if your cartridge is borderline, Iowa tells you to ask a conservation officer. Good advice.
Pennsylvania — not a straight-wall state at all. Readers ask constantly. Pennsylvania allows centerfire rifles statewide for deer. Straight-walls only became a talking point there because the Game Commission added them as a legal option in most Special Regulations Areas — Allegheny, Bucks, Chester, Delaware, Montgomery and Philadelphia counties — back in 2021. Centerfire rifle hunting is still prohibited in all of Philadelphia County and at Ridley Creek and Tyler state parks. Where you may shoot a rifle in Pennsylvania is complicated county by county, so pull the current Hunting & Trapping Digest for your WMU.
Illinois — single-shot only, for one more season. Under Public Act 102-0932, a legal Illinois deer rifle must be a centerfire of .30 caliber or larger, either a bottleneck case no longer than 1.4 inches or a straight-walled cartridge, in a factory load with at least 500 foot-pounds at the muzzle. No FMJ. And it must hold exactly one round in magazine and chamber combined — having a larger magazine nearby makes it illegal. That’s still the rule for 2026. The IDNR FAQ confirms the limit rises to three rounds on 1 January 2027 under Senate Bill 2756 (Public Act 104-0627). Hunting Illinois this year? Buy a single shot.
Quick Picks
| Rifle | Chambering | Best for | Approx. Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ruger American Gen II | .350 Legend | Best all-around | $550 (Cabela’s) |
| Glenfield Model A | .350 Legend | Best budget bolt gun | $430 (Sportsman’s Guide) |
| Henry Single-Shot | .350 Legend | Youth, Illinois, first rifle | $540 (Cabela’s) |
| Ruger American Gen II | .450 Bushmaster | Hardest hitter under $600 | $570 (Sportsman’s Guide) |
| Henry Steel Side Gate | .45-70 Gov’t | Timber and tracking | $950 (Cabela’s) |
| Henry X Model | .360 Buckhammer | Modern lever, optics-friendly | $970 (Cabela’s) |
Prices checked 21 October 2026. Cabela’s figures are CLUB member prices; Sportsman’s Guide shows a slightly lower Buyers Club price on each.
Ruger American Gen II — .350 Legend
Ruger’s spec sheet for model 46906 lists a 20-inch spiral-fluted barrel, 6.4 pounds bare, a 5-round AR-pattern magazine and the Marksman trigger adjustable from 3 to 5 pounds. Two features earn it the top spot: a factory radial-port muzzle brake, and a length of pull adjustable from 12 to 13.75 inches by pulling a spacer. One rifle fits a 12-year-old and fits you. Ruger’s MSRP is $769; Cabela’s has had it at about $550.
Pros: Light, genuinely adjustable, good trigger, brake takes the edge off an already mild cartridge. Cons: No scope included, and the brake makes an easy-shooting round loud — wear plugs and muffs on the bench. Ruger lists this exact configuration as limited availability.
Glenfield Model A — .350 Legend
Ruger brought the old Glenfield name back in 2025 as its value line. The Model A has a 20-inch cold-hammer-forged threaded barrel, a factory Picatinny rail, a detachable box magazine and a $499 MSRP. Sportsman’s Guide has been listing the .350 Legend version right around $430, which is remarkable for an American-made bolt gun that arrives rail-ready.
Pros: Cheapest credible new straight-wall bolt gun we found. Threaded muzzle and a rail you don’t have to buy. Cons: Plain stock, no brake, nothing adjustable. You feel more recoil than with the Gen II, and no scope in the box.
Henry Single-Shot — .350 Legend
Model H015-350. Cabela’s lists a 22-inch barrel, 7.18 pounds, a brass-bead front and folding adjustable rear sight, American walnut, and a barrel drilled and tapped for a scope mount. In Illinois a single shot is the law this season. For a kid’s first centerfire, the extra weight and mild Legend recoil are exactly right, and one cartridge at a time enforces the patience that makes good shooters.
Pros: Simple, safe to teach on, handsome, legal everywhere on this list. Cons: One shot. A follow-up on a wounded deer is slow, and a fixed walnut stock is long for a small shooter.
Check the current price of the Henry Single-Shot Rifle – .350 Legend at Cabela’s
Ruger American Gen II — .450 Bushmaster
Same rifle, bigger hammer. Ruger’s spec sheet for model 46905 lists a 20-inch Cerakote barrel, 6.4 pounds, a 3-round single-stack magazine, an 11/16-24 threaded muzzle with a radial-port brake, and the same adjustable length of pull. Hornady’s BLACK 250-grain FTX leaves a 20-inch barrel at 2,200 fps for 2,687 foot-pounds. That is a lot of cartridge for a 6.4-pound rifle.
Pros: The most muzzle energy of anything here under $600. The brake and pad help more than you’d think. Cons: It kicks hard, and a flinching hunter misses. Don’t buy this for a youth or a recoil-sensitive shooter, and don’t buy it if you won’t practice. Three rounds, and ammo costs real money.
Henry Steel Side Gate — .45-70 Government
Model H010G. Cabela’s lists an 18.43-inch barrel, 7 pounds, 4+1, American walnut, and a fully adjustable semi-buckhorn rear with a brass bead up front. The side gate lets you top it off without unloading. Federal’s Fusion 300-grain load leaves the muzzle at 1,850 fps with 2,280 foot-pounds — plenty for any whitetail that ever walked.
Pros: Fast to point, fast to reload, the best gun here for still-hunting a creek bottom or following a blood trail. Cons: Heavy recoil, iron sights only out of the box, and $950 is real money. Scoping a lever takes some thought.
Henry X Model — .360 Buckhammer
Henry lists the .360 Buckhammer X Model (H009X-360BH) at 21.375 inches, 8.07 pounds, 5 rounds, fiber-optic sights front and rear, a Picatinny rail, M-Lok slots, a side loading gate and a 5/8×24 threaded muzzle, at $1,129 MSRP. Cabela’s has it closer to $970. Remington lists the 180-grain Core-Lokt at 2,400 fps — flatter than .45-70, noticeably softer than .450 Bushmaster. At eight pounds it’s the gentlest big-bore lever here.
Pros: A lever gun that mounts a scope properly. Mild recoil for the energy. Clears Ohio’s .357 minimum with its .358-inch bullet. Cons: Ammo is the problem — see below. Heaviest rifle here, and the priciest.
The AR option
If you want a semi-auto, the .350 Legend AR works — Ruger’s AR-556 MPR is chambered for it. We couldn’t find one at Bass Pro, Cabela’s or Sportsman’s Guide today, so there’s no link here; try Sportsman’s Warehouse or a local shop. Mind Ohio’s three-round limit and Illinois’s single-shot rule.
These are 150 to 200-yard rifles, and here’s the proof
Straight-walls are short, fat and slow, and they shed velocity fast. Hornady’s table for the 170-grain .350 Legend American Whitetail shows 2,200 fps and 1,827 foot-pounds at the muzzle, 1,529 fps and 882 foot-pounds at 200 yards, and 19.4 inches of drop at 300 off a 200-yard zero. Hornady’s 250-grain .450 Bushmaster goes 2,200 to 1,515 fps over the same distance and drops 19.3 inches at 300. Federal’s 300-grain .45-70 Fusion falls 41.6 inches at 300.
Two things follow. Soft points need speed to open up, and by 250 yards these are marginal on expansion. And a foot and a half of drop at 300 is a wounded deer, not a dead one. Pick a 150-yard zero, know your 200-yard hold, pass anything farther.
Our full breakdown of which loads shoot best is here:
Read next: Best 350 Legend Ammo For Deer
What ammo actually costs right now
Checked today, per box of 20.
| Chambering | What we found | Availability |
|---|---|---|
| .350 Legend | $17.99 Winchester White Box FMJ (range only); $26.99 Hornady American Whitetail 170 gr | Easy |
| .450 Bushmaster | $40.49 Hornady BLACK 250 gr FTX; $47.99 Federal Power-Shok 300 gr | Decent |
| .45-70 Gov’t | $44.99 Grizzly 405 gr; $57.99 Federal Fusion 300 gr; $72.99 Grizzly +P 300 gr | Decent, pricey |
| .360 Buckhammer | $45.99 to $56.99 direct from Remington | Thin |
The .350 Legend wins on both counts and it isn’t close: cheapest to feed, easiest to find on a shelf in November. FMJ is illegal for deer in Indiana and Illinois, so the white-box stuff is practice ammo only.
.360 Buckhammer is the one to think hard about. Remington lists five loads and all show available, but no retailer we checked stocks the caliber, and Sportsman’s Guide has no .360 Buckhammer ammo category at all. Great cartridge, mail-order supply. .44 Magnum sits in between — ubiquitous as handgun ammo, and a Henry Big Boy is the obvious rifle for it, though Cabela’s pages for those returned a site error today, so we won’t quote a price.
Optics: keep it simple
Nothing here needs much magnification. A 2-7×33 or 3-9×40 with a duplex or simple BDC reticle covers every shot you’ll take, and the low end helps on a close deer in timber. None of the rifles above ships with a scope, so budget for one. A Vortex Crossfire II 3-9×40 with the Dead-Hold BDC reticle has been running about $126 at OpticsPlanet, about right for a $450 to $600 rifle. Spend your money on the mount, not the magnification.
Check the current price of the Vortex Crossfire II 3-9x40mm Rifle Scope, 1in Tube at OpticsPlanet
Frequently Asked Questions
Is .350 Legend legal in Ohio?
Yes. Ohio’s rule covers straight-walled cartridges from .357 to .50 caliber (the administrative code reads .515 as the maximum), and the 2026-27 booklet names the .350 Legend as qualifying. Remember the three-round limit during gun season.
Can I use a regular .308 or 6.5 Creedmoor in Michigan now?
In the Lower Peninsula for 2026, yes — the 2026 summary says the limited firearms deer zone has been eliminated and all legal firearms may be used across the Lower Peninsula beginning 12 September 2026. Your straight-wall rifle is still legal, just no longer the only option. Confirm with the DNR first, because one of their own subpages still showed the old restrictions when we checked.
Does .450 Bushmaster kick too much for a 12-year-old?
For most kids, yes. It launches a 250-grain bullet at 2,200 fps out of a 6.4-pound rifle, and a young shooter who flinches will miss or wound. Put them behind a .350 Legend instead — the Ruger Gen II with its stock shortened to 12 inches, or the heavier Henry single shot.
What’s the real maximum range on a straight-wall deer rifle?
Call it 200 yards, and 150 is better. Factory tables for .350 Legend and .450 Bushmaster both show velocity dropping below 1,550 fps by 200 yards and roughly 19 inches of drop at 300. Soft points stop expanding reliably as they slow, so the ethical limit arrives before the mechanical one.
Is .360 Buckhammer worth buying into?
It’s a genuinely good cartridge — flatter than .45-70, softer than .450 Bushmaster, legal in every straight-wall state we checked. The catch is supply: we found no retailer carrying the ammo today, so you’d be ordering direct. One box a year, fine. If you like to practice, pick .350 Legend.
What we’d do this week
Hunting Ohio, Indiana, Iowa or southern Michigan in the next six weeks without a rifle? Order the Ruger American Gen II in .350 Legend, put a 3-9×40 on it, and buy two boxes of the Hornady 170-grain — one to zero with, one to hunt with. If money’s tight, the Glenfield Model A does the same job for $120 less. Buying for a kid, or hunting Illinois? The Henry single shot.
Then square away the rest of the kit:
Read next: Deer Hunting Gear Checklist
One last time, plainly: every regulation above was read off each state’s own current published rules on 21 October 2026, but rules get amended and zones get redrawn. Pull up your state’s regulations before you buy a rifle, and before you carry it into the woods.
