If you’ve spent enough time shooting and fixing guns, you know some models seem born to eat extractors. A good extractor quietly does its job—grabs the rim, pulls the case, and gets it out of the way. But on certain rifles and pistols, they’re weak links that bend, chip, or snap before the gun’s even broken in. Sometimes it’s a design flaw, other times it’s metallurgy, bad chamber polish, or rough cycling. Either way, you end up chasing brass with a cleaning rod more often than you’d like. These are the guns that teach you to carry spares.
Remington 742 Woodsmaster
If you’ve ever owned a Woodsmaster, you probably know this one by heart. The rifle’s semi-auto action can be hard on extractors, especially when carbon builds up in the chamber. That sticky brass and sharp extraction angle put extra stress on the part until it eventually cracks. Once it does, you’re manually prying cases out of the chamber. Replacement parts aren’t cheap, either, and swapping them takes patience. The 742 was great when new, but after decades of use, the worn bolt face and soft extractor steel make it one of the fastest ways to learn armorer skills.
M1 Garand
The M1 Garand isn’t usually called unreliable, but its extractor is known to fail if you shoot it dry or use modern ammo that cycles harder than what it was built for. The spring-loaded extractor can chip under high stress or if the bolt face gets fouled. Old rifles with worn parts or improperly hardened replacements tend to lose that tiny claw sooner than you think. When it goes, you’ll know—spent brass stays right where it started. Keep it clean, use proper grease, and carry a spare extractor if you plan on running one hard.
AR-15 variants with cheap bolts
A good AR-15 extractor lasts for thousands of rounds, but the cheaper rifles with bargain bolts and mystery metal parts often fail fast. Poor heat-treating, weak extractor springs, and rough machining mean they lose tension or snap under normal cycling. Once the extractor lip rounds off, cases start slipping, and malfunctions follow fast. The fix isn’t hard—upgrade to a quality bolt carrier group—but too many shooters learn that lesson at the range. If you’re buying a rifle under $500, check the bolt quality before trusting it for anything serious.
AK-47 clones with out-of-spec bolts
The real AK rifles are known for reliability, but many modern clones don’t share that reputation. Poorly heat-treated bolts, miscut extractor grooves, and sharp ejection angles can all cause chipped or broken extractors. Combine that with cheap ammo and hard primers, and you’ve got a recipe for extraction failure. Some of these rifles work fine for a while, but when they break, they do it fast. It’s not a knock on the original design—it’s the sloppy reproductions that give the platform a bad name. Quality AKs don’t mind grime. The knockoffs hate it.
Springfield XD series
The XD line earned a loyal following, but it’s also known among armorers for extractor issues. The spring-loaded extractor design can be finicky with dirty chambers or steel-cased ammo, leading to chipped edges or lost tension. Once that lip wears, extraction becomes unreliable, and failure-to-extract jams start piling up. You can replace the part, but it’s not as easy as swapping one in a Glock or M&P. The XD’s design puts more stress on that tiny claw than it should, and when it goes, it tends to go suddenly—usually in the middle of a range day.
Ruger Mini-14
Ruger’s Mini-14 has plenty of strengths, but the extractor isn’t one of them. Hard cycling, overgassed actions, and thin case rims—especially on reloads—take a toll. The rifle throws brass with authority, and that violent ejection eventually wears the extractor edge down or chips it completely. Older models were worse, with inconsistent heat treatment and sharp machining that accelerated wear. The newer versions are better, but anyone running an older Mini knows to keep a spare extractor and spring handy. Once it breaks, you’re not clearing cases without a rod and a few choice words.
Remington 700 (older models with heavy use)
Bolt guns usually baby their extractors, but the older Remington 700s sometimes don’t. The small C-clip style extractor in early models can crack if you run hot loads or a dirty chamber. It’s not a catastrophic failure, but when it happens, you’ll feel it—spent brass will stick, and the bolt feels rough. Many gunsmiths swap in aftermarket Sako-style extractors to fix it permanently. It’s a reminder that even precision rifles can wear out small parts over time. If your 700’s seen thousands of rounds, that little clip might be your next headache.
KelTec Sub2000
The KelTec Sub2000 is fun and handy, but extractor failures are common enough to make experienced owners keep spares. The part is small, roughly finished, and often made of softer steel than it should be. Combine that with tight tolerances and blowback operation, and the extractor works overtime on every shot. Dirty chambers and hot 9mm loads make things worse, wearing down the lip quickly. Once it rounds off or cracks, you’re in for stovepipes and failures to eject. It’s a clever design for portability—but it’s hard on parts that do the dirty work.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
Calibers That Shouldn’t Even Be On the Shelf Anymore
Rifles That Shouldn’t Be Trusted Past 100 Yards
*This article was developed with AI-powered tools and has been carefully reviewed by our editors.
