Most hunters will help a buddy out if they can. That part is not unusual. Somebody’s short on gear, somebody’s trying to get into hunting, somebody needs a rifle for a season, and if there’s enough trust there, a lot of guys will say yes. But a Reddit thread in r/Hunting showed exactly why so many people have gotten more careful about that over the years. What started as a simple question about whether it is taboo to ask to borrow a gun turned into a pile of stories from hunters who learned the hard way that loaning out firearms can go south fast.
The story that stood out came from one commenter who kept it short and painful. He said he loaned a rifle to a friend for deer season and got it back with “apparent rust,” the magazine missing, and the stock broken. He added that it cost him a few hundred dollars to get the rifle restored, then summed it up the way most hunters probably would after something like that: “Needless to say; I won’t be letting him borrow anything again.” That one comment probably told the whole lesson better than a full page of advice could.
If you’ve spent any time around hunting gear, you already know why that hit a nerve. A rifle is not like loaning out a folding chair or a cheap cooler. Even an old, plain deer rifle usually has a little story behind it, and even when it does not, it still represents money, time, maintenance, and trust. Returning one with rust, a missing magazine, and a broken stock is not just carelessness. To most outdoorsmen, that reads like a man either had no respect for somebody else’s equipment or no respect for the favor that was done for him.
The rest of the thread backed that up in a hurry. One commenter said a good friend will happily let you borrow a gun, but the key is bringing it back in “as good or better condition” than you got it. Another hunter shared the exact opposite kind of story and said he let a friend borrow a Remington 700 for his first deer season and got it back cleaned up with an extra box of ammo in the case. That contrast is what makes this thread work so well. It was not full of guys saying nobody should ever borrow a gun. It was full of guys saying borrowed gear tells you a whole lot about a person.
There was also a practical side to the conversation, especially from duck hunters. One commenter pointed out that duck hunting is “notoriously rough on guns” because of bad weather, mud, and sometimes even salt water. That matters because some gear gets loaned into rough conditions by nature. If a man borrows a shotgun for the marsh and brings it back dirty, wet, or starting to rust, nobody should act surprised. That is exactly why hunters kept circling back to the same point in the thread: if someone trusts you with a firearm, taking care of it is part of the deal, not some extra courtesy.
A few of the comments showed that for some hunters, the bigger fear is not damage but what can happen once the gun leaves your sight. One guy told a story about loaning out an old German Mauser through his younger brother for deer season, only to get a call from a game warden because the borrower had never taken hunter safety and did not have a deer permit. The rifle ended up at the sheriff’s office, and the owner had to drive home from college to sort it out. He said he has not lent a gun out since. Stories like that add another layer to why these decisions feel heavier than just lending somebody a tool.
That’s really why this thread felt so familiar. Most hunters are not selfish about gear. A lot of them want to help new people get started, and some even keep what one commenter called “loaner grade firearms” around for exactly that reason. But there is a big difference between helping somebody out and setting yourself up to be disrespected. Once a man gets a rifle back in worse shape than it left, or has to answer questions from a game warden because somebody else got sloppy, the whole idea starts looking a lot less generous and a lot more foolish.
The comments also had a streak of hard-earned common sense running through them. Some hunters said they will let people use a gun if they are hunting together, but not take one off on their own. Others said they only lend to close family or people they trust completely. A few were blunt and said if a person wants to hunt regularly, they need to save up and buy their own gun. That may sound harsh, but after enough bad experiences, a lot of men stop seeing strict boundaries as rude and start seeing them as basic sense.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
