The Handguns That Pickers Have Learned to Check For at Every Shop in Every Town They Visit

Photo credit: Texas Gun Vault/Youtube

When you bounce between small-town gun shops, pawn counters, farm auctions, and dusty glass cases, you start to notice patterns. Certain handguns show up again and again, and the good ones don’t sit there long. The guys who are serious about “picking” used guns aren’t just looking for collector trophies, either. They’re looking for real-world useful pistols: the kind you can carry on a fence line, stash in a truck safe, or trust when the nearest help is a long way off.

What follows are the handguns that seasoned pickers tend to scan for every time they walk into a shop. Some are classics that keep working. Some are oddballs that got discontinued and suddenly got expensive. A few are sleepers that aren’t trendy, but they just plain do the job.

1. Glock 19 (Gen 3 and Gen 4)

Used Glock 19s are the most common “good deal” handgun in America, and that’s exactly why pickers check for them first. You can find one with honest holster wear, night sights that are about done, and three mags for a price that makes sense. Then you clean it, swap springs if you feel like it, and it’s back to work. There’s nothing romantic about it, and that’s kind of the point.

The other reason it’s on the short list is parts and magazines. Every shop has Glock mags. Every backwoods gunsmith can get Glock parts. If you’re traveling and you break an extractor or need sights, you’re not stuck. A Glock 19 isn’t the coolest thing in the case, but it’s hard to argue with a pistol that just runs.

2. Smith & Wesson Model 10

If you grew up around old deputies and rural homeowners, you’ve seen a Model 10 riding in a drawer, a tackle box, or a truck console. These revolvers aren’t fancy, but the good ones have a trigger that makes you grin, and they point naturally. When a clean one shows up at a fair price, pickers pay attention, because it’s real steel and real history without “collector tax” if you shop smart.

What to look at is timing and lockup, and whether somebody bubba’d the grips or filed the front sight. A tight Model 10 is a lifetime gun for simple chores: checking a trap line, walking a property edge, or keeping something trustworthy around the house. .38 Special is still easy to find, and recoil is friendly for just about anyone.

3. Ruger GP100 (4-inch)

The GP100 is one of those revolvers that makes sense if you actually use your guns outdoors. It’s heavy enough to shoot .357 Magnum without punishing you, and built like it expects a hard life. In used cases, you’ll see them with scuffs and cylinder lines, which is fine. A GP100 with a solid double-action pull and clean bore is hard to wear out, and most owners never manage it.

Pickers like them because they’re dependable “do everything” revolvers. Farm carry, backup while bowhunting, trail gun when you’re checking cameras—those are real roles. The downside is weight on the belt, especially in summer, and it’s not a small gun. Still, when you find one with the original grips and a decent price, it’s hard not to bring it home.

4. Colt Detective Special (2-inch)

Old Colt snub-nose revolvers have a feel that’s different, and if you know, you know. The Detective Special is one of those guns that disappears fast when it’s priced like a “used revolver” instead of a “vintage Colt.” The bluing, the lines, the way the action stacks—there’s a reason collectors chase them, but you don’t have to be a collector to appreciate a good one.

The caution here is condition and parts. If it’s out of time or the lockwork is worn, you don’t fix it as easily as a modern Ruger or Smith. But if you find one that’s mechanically right, it’s a classy, practical carry revolver that still makes sense. A lot of folks sold these years ago and regret it now. That one hurts.

5. SIG Sauer P229 (especially .40 trade-ins)

There was a time when police trade-in SIG P229s were everywhere, and the smart buyers filled their safes. Even now, they pop up, usually in .40 S&W, with finish wear and a smooth action from years of holster time. They’re a little chunky, but they shoot flat and feel steady, especially compared to featherweight carry guns that get snappy.

The reason pickers still check for them is value. A clean P229 is a serious duty-grade pistol, and it’s often cheaper than it should be because “.40 is dead” online. I get why some shooters moved on, but the pistol itself is not the problem. If you reload or you don’t mind buying .40, it’s a lot of handgun for the money.

6. Heckler & Koch P7 (PSP/M8)

The HK P7 is one of those guns that makes you stop mid-step when you see it in a case. They’re discontinued, they’re unusual, and they’re unbelievably accurate for their size. The squeeze-cocker is either “the coolest thing ever” or “not for me,” but it’s undeniably well-made. When an older shop prices one like any other used 9mm, a picker’s pulse goes up.

Two realities: they get hot when you run a bunch of rounds, and parts aren’t something you casually grab off a shelf. But for what it is—a compact 9mm with real precision and a unique manual of arms—it’s special. These don’t get cheaper, and they don’t get more common. If you want one, you buy it when you see it and it’s right.

7. Browning Hi-Power (FN or Browning-marked)

A Hi-Power is a classic that still feels good in the hand, even next to modern polymer guns. The grip shape is just right for a lot of shooters, and a good one points like it’s reading your mind. Pickers watch for them because clean originals and good clones have been climbing, and because plenty of owners don’t realize what they’ve got if it’s been sitting in a safe.

They’re not perfect. Some have a heavy trigger due to the magazine disconnect, and you need to pay attention to feed reliability depending on the gun and the magazines. Still, for a steel 9mm with real history and real shootability, it’s hard to go wrong. If you find one with honest wear and good mags, it’s worth a hard look.

8. Smith & Wesson Model 19 (Combat Magnum)

The Model 19 is one of those revolvers that feels “just right” on the hip. It’s lighter and handier than the big N-frames, and the balance is excellent. That’s why pickers keep an eye out, especially for older ones with crisp markings and a clean cylinder face. It’s a gun that carried a lot, worked a lot, and still has a place.

The main thing is not pretending it’s a Ruger. These were built in a time when .357 Magnum was a big deal, but steady diets of hot loads can be rough on them. For most outdoor use—.38s for practice, sensible .357s for serious work—they’re wonderful. And when you find one that hasn’t been abused, it’s hard not to appreciate what a good K-frame can be.

9. Ruger Security-Six

The Security-Six series is one of Ruger’s best “working revolver” ideas, and it’s still a bargain compared to what it should cost. It’s slimmer than a GP100 and carries nicer, but it’s still tough enough for real use. A lot of them show up with worn grips and holster marks, which usually tells you it was carried, not babied.

Pickers check for them because they’re honest guns that don’t need a hype campaign. Timing is usually solid, and they’re not as finicky as some older revolvers can be. If you want a .357 that lives in the truck, rides on an ATV, or hikes through brush, a Security-Six makes sense. When you see one priced like “just another old revolver,” that’s your window.

10. CZ 75B (and pre-B variants)

The CZ 75 has a loyal following for a reason. It’s heavy enough to shoot comfortably, it fits a lot of hands, and the design has been proven for decades. Pickers look for them because plenty of shops still undervalue older CZs, especially if they don’t come with a pile of mags or the finish shows handling wear.

Where the CZ shines is shootability. If you actually put rounds downrange, the low bore axis and weight help you stay on target. The downsides are that some parts and magazines can be more expensive than Glock stuff, and not every local shop stocks CZ bits. Still, for a “real pistol” feel in 9mm, it’s one of the best used buys out there when you stumble onto the right one.

Free for gun owners: If something happened to you tomorrow, would your family know where the guns are, who has the safe combination, or what to do first? Our free Gun Owner’s Family Checklist walks them through it. It takes about 15 minutes to fill out. Get your free copy here.

11. Beretta 92FS (and M9 variants)

Big, wide, and not particularly trendy right now, the Beretta 92 is exactly why it’s a good used counter find. A lot of owners drift away from it because it’s not a compact carry gun, then it lands in a shop for a fair price. The funny part is how well they shoot. The 92 has a soft recoil impulse and a smooth cycling feel that makes range days easy.

Pickers check them because they’re durable and supported. Magazines are everywhere, and parts aren’t hard to get. The things to inspect are the locking block history and general maintenance, especially on very high-mileage guns. But a clean 92FS is a terrific home-defense pistol and range gun. If your hands fit it, you can do a lot worse for the money.

12. Walther PPK / PPK/S

The PPK has a reputation that’s bigger than the gun, and that’s part of the appeal. It’s also genuinely handy in a pocket with the right holster, and it carries flat. Pickers watch for older German or well-regarded production runs, because values bounce around and some shops price them based on size instead of what they are.

You do need to be honest about what you’re buying. They can be picky with ammo, and recoil in .380 can feel sharp for such a small steel pistol. Some will bite the web of your hand if your grip is high. Still, a good PPK is a neat little carry gun and a classic. If you find one that locks up well and comes with the right mags, it’s worth a closer look.

13. Ruger Mark II (and Mark I)

Every rimfire pistol doesn’t have to be a tactical trainer. The Ruger Mark II is one of the best “shoot it forever” .22 pistols ever made, and used ones are all over the place if you’re patient. Pickers check for them because a solid .22 handgun is more useful than folks admit: small game, pests around the barn, cheap practice, and teaching new shooters without drama.

Yes, field stripping can be a hassle until you learn it. Ask me how I know. But these guns tend to be accurate, reliable with decent ammo, and built like they’re not interested in your opinion. When you find one with a good barrel, a clean crown, and a trigger that hasn’t been butchered, you’re looking at a pistol you’ll still be shooting years from now.

14. Colt Woodsman

If you want to see pickers move fast, put a clean Colt Woodsman in a case with a normal price tag. These old .22s have a smoothness and balance that’s hard to replicate. They’re the kind of pistol you’d actually carry while working around a place, because they’re accurate, light enough, and point naturally. When you pick one up, you can see why they got famous.

The catch is that condition matters, and parts aren’t like modern Ruger parts. You want one that hasn’t been messed with, and you want to check magazines closely. But if you find a good one, it’s not just a collectible. It’s a practical field .22 that’s enjoyable to shoot. There’s a reason the old-timers kept them.

15. Smith & Wesson Model 41

The Model 41 isn’t a casual purchase, even used, but it’s one of those pistols that rewards you every time you shoot it. If you’ve ever shot a really good .22 target pistol, you know the feeling: the trigger breaks clean, the sights sit still, and suddenly you look better than you are. Pickers check for them because they occasionally show up from an estate or a safe clean-out where the shop doesn’t want to sit on it.

This is less about “field carry” and more about getting a top-tier rimfire without paying new pricing. Inspect the muzzle, check the magazines, and look for signs it was stored poorly. If it’s right, it’s a pistol you can build skill with for decades. Not everyone needs one, but the folks who understand them tend to keep them.

16. Springfield Armory XD (especially early XD-9)

The XD line gets dumped on in online gun talk, which is exactly why pickers look for clean used examples. They’re often priced low, and many of them run just fine for years. The grip safety isn’t everyone’s favorite, but it’s not automatically a deal-breaker either. For a glovebox gun or a basic home-defense pistol, an XD can be a reasonable buy if the price is right.

Where you need to be picky is magazines and overall wear. Make sure it comes with at least a couple factory mags, because that’s where the value can vanish. Also pay attention to whether the seller is including the original accessories, since those packages vary. I wouldn’t choose an XD over everything else, but I also wouldn’t ignore a clean one at a true bargain.

17. Smith & Wesson M&P9 (1.0)

The original M&P9 is a classic “traded in because the new version came out” pistol. The 2.0 trigger and texture got everyone’s attention, so the 1.0s started showing up used at prices that make you look twice. Pickers like that, because the base gun is reliable, ergonomic, and easy to live with, even if the trigger isn’t as crisp as newer models.

This is a practical buy for a working person. Holsters are everywhere, magazines aren’t exotic, and the gun carries well. If you find one with decent sights and a clean slide, it’s a smart grab. The biggest question is whether you personally like the trigger feel, and that’s something you can usually judge with a dry fire at the counter (safely, with permission). For a do-it-all 9mm, it’s a sleeper.

18. Ruger LCP (original)

The original LCP is not a fun range gun. It’s small, it’s snappy, and the sights are more like suggestions than a real aiming system. And yet, pickers still check for them because they fill a real niche: a gun you can actually carry when you’re wearing light clothes, running into town, or just need something that disappears in a pocket holster.

Used LCPs show up cheap, and that’s fine as long as you understand what you’re buying. You’re not buying a pistol to shoot 500 rounds a weekend. You’re buying a “better than nothing” carry option that’s light enough to be there every day. Check function, check magazines, and be honest about your own tolerance for recoil. For the right person, it’s a tool, not a toy.

19. Taurus Model 85 (steel frames)

Taurus revolvers are a mixed bag, and I’m not going to pretend otherwise. But the steel-frame Model 85 has earned its way into a lot of pockets over the years, and there are good ones out there. Pickers look for them because they’re often priced low, and when you find one that’s tight and timed correctly, it can be a serviceable little .38 for basic carry.

This is one where you inspect carefully. Check cylinder endshake, lockup, and the trigger feel. If anything seems off, walk away, because you’re not saving money if it becomes a project. But if it checks out and you want a simple revolver that can ride in a coat pocket during deer season chores, the Model 85 can fill that role. It’s not glamorous. It’s just handy.

20. Colt 1911 Government Model (Series 70 style)

A real Colt Government Model still makes pickers slow down. Not because every 1911 is magic, but because Colt on the slide still means something, and older examples are getting harder to find in un-messed-with condition. You’ll see plenty of 1911s in cases, but a clean Colt that hasn’t been “customized” into problems is a different deal.

The trick is knowing what you’re looking at. A tasteful set of sights is one thing; a home-dremeled feed ramp and mystery parts is another. When you find a solid Colt with a good barrel, decent trigger, and original feel, it’s a pistol that holds its own for range use and can still serve for defense with the right setup. It’s heavy, it’s old-school, and it still works.

The fun part about checking these isn’t just chasing value. It’s seeing what real people actually carried, actually trusted, and finally decided to part with. If you’re going to do some picking yourself, handle the gun like you mean it, inspect it like you’re the one betting your safety on it, and don’t get hypnotized by a low price tag. The best used handgun buy is the one that fits your life and will still be running when the new-gun excitement wears off.