Every gun owner has a story about the one they should have bought. It was sitting in the case, hanging on the used rack, or tucked behind something newer. The price seemed a little high at the time, or the buyer told himself he would think about it and come back later.
Then it was gone. Sometimes the same model never showed up again. Sometimes it did, but the price had doubled. Other times, the buyer simply realized too late that the gun had the exact mix of quality, usefulness, and character he kept trying to find later. These are the guns people regret walking away from.
Colt Woodsman Match Target
The Colt Woodsman Match Target was easy to admire and still leave behind if you were only shopping for a casual .22 pistol. It looked nice, but plenty of buyers told themselves a cheaper rimfire would do the same job.
That decision usually aged badly. The Match Target had balance, accuracy, and old Colt workmanship that modern rimfire pistols rarely duplicate. It was not just a plinker. It was the kind of pistol that made slow range time feel better. People who walked away from a clean one usually remember the price because it looks painfully low now.
Remington 700 Mountain Rifle LSS
The Remington 700 Mountain Rifle LSS had the kind of setup hunters should have paid more attention to. Stainless steel, laminated stock, lighter contour, and the familiar Model 700 action made it a practical rifle for ugly weather and long walks.
Some buyers passed because it looked like just another 700 variant. That was the mistake. The LSS version had a useful blend of weather resistance and traditional hunting feel without going fully synthetic. A good one in .270, .30-06, 7mm-08, or .280 Remington is not something you casually replace. Hunters who left one on the rack often wish they had grabbed it.
Smith & Wesson Model 24
The Smith & Wesson Model 24 was never the obvious revolver for everyone. A big N-frame chambered in .44 Special seemed less exciting than a .44 Magnum and less practical than a smaller .357.
That is why too many people walked away. The Model 24 is smooth, accurate, and far more pleasant to shoot than many heavy magnum revolvers. It gives you big-bore revolver character without needing punishing loads. Clean examples have become the kind of guns revolver people notice immediately. Passing on one because it was “only” a .44 Special was usually a bad call.
Winchester Model 9422M
The Winchester Model 9422M looked like a neat .22 Magnum lever gun, but for years some buyers did not see enough reason to pay more than they would for a basic .22 rifle. It seemed like something they could always find later.
That assumption turned into regret. The 9422M combines Winchester lever-action quality with the extra reach and punch of .22 Magnum. It is useful for small game, pests, and field carry, but still fun enough for casual shooting. Once clean examples got expensive, the people who walked away started realizing they had passed on one of the best rimfire lever guns ever made.
Browning BSS
The Browning BSS was easy to pass over when side-by-sides were not getting much attention. Many shotgun buyers wanted over-unders or semi-autos, so a sturdy Japanese-made double did not always seem urgent.
Now it looks like one of those guns people should have bought on sight. The BSS is strong, well-made, and useful enough for real field work instead of just looking pretty. It has a reputation for durability that makes it stand apart from cheaper doubles. Anyone who walked away from a clean 20-gauge or 12-gauge example probably still thinks about it.
Ruger Blackhawk Hunter
The Ruger Blackhawk Hunter was not always the first revolver buyers chased. It looked specialized with its integral scope ring cuts and hunting purpose, and some people figured a standard Blackhawk or Redhawk made more sense.
Later, that specialization became the reason people wanted one. The Blackhawk Hunter is strong, accurate, and ready for handgun hunting without needing awkward mounting solutions. In chamberings like .44 Magnum or .45 Colt, it fills a serious field role. Walking away from one usually hurts once you decide you actually want a scoped single-action hunting revolver.
Marlin 336 Texan
The Marlin 336 Texan had straight-grip styling that made it stand apart from the standard pistol-grip 336 rifles. For some buyers, that difference was easy to overlook when .30-30 lever guns were still common.
Now the Texan has a lot more pull. The straight stock gives it a cleaner, more traditional lever-gun feel, and older Marlins have only become more desirable. It is still a practical deer rifle, but it also has enough character to make it memorable. People who walked away because it was “just another Marlin” usually wish they had looked closer.
SIG Sauer P232
The SIG Sauer P232 was one of those pistols buyers often admired but did not always buy. It was sleek, beautifully made, and easy to like, but the .380 chambering and limited capacity made some people hesitate.
That hesitation is exactly what they regret now. The P232 has a level of refinement that most modern pocket pistols do not touch. It is slim, elegant, and pleasant enough to shoot compared with tiny polymer .380s. It may not win a modern defensive spec-sheet fight, but it was never just about specs. It was a classic SIG pocket pistol with real style.
Weatherby Mark V Fibermark
The Weatherby Mark V Fibermark gave hunters Weatherby strength and speed in a more practical synthetic-stocked package. It lacked the high-gloss drama of the Deluxe, but that made it easier to hunt hard.
Some buyers walked away because it did not look as flashy as other Mark V rifles. That was short-sighted. The Fibermark was built for people who wanted Weatherby performance without worrying about every scratch in fancy walnut. In serious chamberings, it made a lot of sense. A clean one today is exactly the kind of rifle Weatherby fans wish they had bought sooner.
Smith & Wesson Model 39-2
The Smith & Wesson Model 39-2 was often overlooked because it was a single-stack 9mm in a world that eventually wanted more capacity. Many buyers handled one, liked it, and still walked away for something newer.
Years later, the 39-2 looks much better. It is slim, handsome, and historically important as one of the classic American double-action 9mm pistols. The alloy frame keeps it carryable, and the old Smith quality gives it a feel newer guns often lack. People who passed on clean examples when they were affordable usually regret choosing capacity over character.
Ruger 44 Deerfield Carbine
The Ruger 44 Deerfield Carbine was easy to misunderstand if you did not hunt thick cover. A semi-auto .44 Magnum carbine with a rotary magazine seemed niche compared with bolt guns, ARs, and lever actions.
That niche is exactly why people want it now. The Deerfield is handy, quick, and useful for short-range deer, hogs, and woods work. It carries like a real hunting carbine and hits harder than its size suggests. Buyers who walked away because it seemed odd often learn later that nobody makes many rifles quite like it anymore.
Beretta 682 Gold E
The Beretta 682 Gold E was never cheap, so some clay shooters walked away thinking they could make do with something less expensive. That made sense in the moment, especially if they were not fully committed to sporting clays or trap.
But a good target shotgun is hard to replace once you understand fit and balance. The 682 Gold E had durability, handling, and competition credibility that made it a serious long-term gun. Many shooters eventually spend more trying to get back to that same level. Passing on one that fit well was usually a mistake.
CZ 527 Lux
The CZ 527 Lux was easy to pass over because it looked traditional and a little unusual compared with American bolt guns. The hogback stock, iron sights, mini-Mauser action, and small-cartridge focus did not appeal to everyone right away.
Now those details are the reason people miss it. The 527 Lux was handy, accurate, and full of character. In cartridges like .223 Remington, .22 Hornet, or 7.62×39, it made a great walking rifle for small game, predators, and light hunting. Buyers who walked away because it looked different often wish they had recognized how special the little CZ really was.
Dan Wesson Specialist
The Dan Wesson Specialist was one of those 1911s buyers sometimes admired but passed on because it cost more than basic production pistols. It had the rail, sights, checkering, and serious-duty look, but the price made some people hesitate.
That hesitation can sting later. The Specialist gave shooters a strong blend of fit, finish, accuracy, and hard-use 1911 features without jumping into full custom money. It was not just a pretty range pistol. It felt like a 1911 built to be used. People who walked away often end up spending more later trying to buy the same confidence.
Winchester Model 1886 Extra Light
The Winchester Model 1886 Extra Light was never an everyday lever gun, and that made some buyers cautious. Big cartridges, old-school design, and higher prices kept people from treating it like an impulse buy.
But anyone who likes powerful lever actions usually regrets walking away from a clean one. The Extra Light version gives the 1886 design a handier field feel while keeping the strength and authority that made the action famous. In .45-70 or similar chamberings, it is the kind of rifle that feels special immediately. Walking away from one rarely feels smart later.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
