Some pistols are great until they aren’t. You clean them, shoot quality ammo, run decent mags, and still find yourself swapping recoil springs like you’re keeping a stash of spares in your sock drawer. That’s not normal wear—that’s poor design or mismatched internals. The recoil spring is supposed to manage slide velocity, soften felt recoil, and keep things in time. When it’s constantly giving out, something’s off. Some guns are oversprung from the factory. Others are undersprung to make up for poor slide geometry or to pass function tests with underpowered ammo. Either way, when the recoil spring fails, you get feeding issues, slide battering, or cracked parts. And you don’t want that halfway through a training weekend—or worse—when it’s the only pistol on your hip.
Sig Sauer P365
The P365 changed the concealed carry market, but early models had a tough time holding onto recoil springs. A lot of folks noticed sluggish slide return or inconsistent ejection patterns after just a few hundred rounds.
It wasn’t uncommon to hear about premature wear on the dual recoil spring assembly. That small, compact slide is doing a lot of work, and the spring system has to handle higher slide velocities in a tight footprint. Newer variants fixed some of that, but if you’ve got an older P365 and you’re putting real range time on it, you better have a few spare spring assemblies on hand. Especially if you’re running hotter defensive ammo.
Walther PPS M2
The PPS M2 is a great-shooting single-stack, but its recoil spring system tends to wear faster than most expect. After a few hundred rounds, you might feel the slide speed up or start noticing inconsistent ejection.
That’s often a sign the recoil spring is losing its tension. The gun’s low bore axis helps mitigate felt recoil, but it also demands a tight-tolerance spring system. If you’re not replacing it regularly, you’ll see more muzzle flip and possibly feed issues. Walther didn’t give much guidance on spring life either, which has left some owners in the dark. If you carry this one, replace the spring often and don’t wait for failures to start showing up.
Springfield XD-S
The XD-S is known for its snappy recoil and stiff springs. Trouble is, that recoil spring takes a beating—and it doesn’t take much to wear it down. The single-stack .45 version is especially rough on the assembly.
Once that spring starts to fatigue, the whole timing of the gun shifts. You’ll start to see failures to return to battery or premature slide lock. Some folks try to stretch the spring’s life, but it usually ends in a trip back to the bench. Springfield’s dual-spring design works when fresh, but it’s sensitive to wear. If you shoot this one often, get used to replacing that spring more than you’d think.
Kimber Micro 9
Kimber’s Micro 9 packs 9mm into a 1911-style micro platform—and it’s harder on recoil springs than you’d expect. That small slide moves fast and hits hard, especially with defensive loads.
It’s common for users to feel the slide slamming harder after a couple hundred rounds. That’s the spring giving out. Once the recoil spring starts to soften, you’ll see everything from stovepipes to failure-to-return-to-battery issues. Kimber doesn’t offer much support in terms of spring replacement intervals, but most owners learn quickly to keep extras on hand. If you’re carrying it, treat the spring like a wear item—because it is.
Glock 43
Glocks usually have excellent spring life, but the 43 is one of the few models that seems to wear springs faster than expected. The compact single-stack frame and small slide don’t offer much cushion, so that spring takes a beating.
When it starts to go, you’ll notice weak ejection and maybe a few FTFs creeping in. It’s subtle at first, but enough rounds downrange and you’ll start to feel the difference. Glock’s recoil assemblies aren’t expensive, and they’re easy to swap—but you need to stay ahead of it. If you’re running the 43 hard, especially in classes or training sessions, keep that spring fresh.
Kahr CW9
Kahr pistols have a unique feel—smooth triggers and good ergonomics—but their recoil spring life can be unpredictable. The CW9 in particular has a tendency to wear springs out quickly, especially when you’re using hotter ammo.
Some owners report needing to swap springs every 500 to 800 rounds just to maintain reliable cycling. You’ll start seeing sluggish return, light battery lockup, and occasional feed issues when the spring goes soft. Kahr uses a full-length guide rod and captured spring, but even with that setup, it doesn’t hold up to regular use unless you’re staying on top of replacements. If this is your carry gun, check spring tension often.
Desert Eagle .50 AE
The Desert Eagle is more range toy than duty gun, but it deserves a mention here. That massive slide and brutal recoil chew through springs like nothing else. If you’re shooting hot .50 AE loads, your recoil spring might not even last a full box of ammo.
Most owners who shoot these regularly know the drill—spring life is short, and slide velocity will beat the gun up if you don’t replace it fast enough. Failure to feed, failure to return to battery, or even frame damage can show up if the spring gets too weak. The big gas system helps, but it doesn’t make the gun forgiving. You either replace the spring often, or you replace broken parts.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
Calibers That Shouldn’t Even Be On the Shelf Anymore
Rifles That Shouldn’t Be Trusted Past 100 Yards
*This article was developed with AI-powered tools and has been carefully reviewed by our editors.
