Photo credit: SPN Firearms/Youtube
You can spot the “review-chasers” at any public range. They’re the ones with three brand-new pistols in foam cases, a pocket full of different magazines, and a face that says they’re hoping today is the day one of them finally feels like “the one.” I get it. I’ve bought stuff because some clean-talking guy on a video swore it was the best carry gun ever made, and I’ve also watched that same gun end up on the used shelf six months later with the original box and one lonely range trip on it.
After a few years of that, serious shooters usually drift toward a smaller group of handguns. Not because they’re flashy, but because they work when they’re dirty, you can find magazines in any gun shop, holsters actually exist for them, and the controls feel right under stress. Here are 20 pistols I keep seeing in the hands (and safes) of folks who finally stopped buying whatever was getting reviewed that week.
1. Glock 19 (Gen 3/4/5)
This is the pistol a lot of guys “graduate” to after flirting with tiny compacts, oddball ergonomics, and bargain-bin experiments. It isn’t romantic, and it isn’t rare. It just runs, shoots well enough to embarrass bad habits, and it carries without making you miserable.
Magazines are everywhere, parts are everywhere, and every holster maker on earth makes something that fits. If you only owned one do-it-all 9mm, this is why it keeps showing up in that conversation.
2. Glock 17 (Gen 3/4/5)
When folks stop pretending a micro-compact is fun for long range sessions, they often end up here. The longer grip and sight radius make it easier to shoot well, especially when you’re doing more than slow-fire at seven yards.
It’s also the pistol that tends to become the “loaner” for new shooters because it’s simple and forgiving. If it’s boring, good. Boring is reliable.
3. Glock 26
The 26 is what happens when someone realizes they want a small gun, not a tiny gun. It’s thick, it’s a little brick-like, and it disappears better than it looks like it should.
It also gives you flexibility with magazines, which matters more than people admit. You can run flush mags for carry, then stick a bigger mag in it when you’re hiking the back forty or teaching a family member.
4. SIG Sauer P365
This one changed what “small” meant for a lot of shooters. It carries like a little gun but shoots like it’s trying to be taken seriously. That’s the whole point.
There are a lot of variants now, and not everyone needs to chase each new one. The basic idea is solid: good capacity, decent sights, real-world carry size, and enough aftermarket support to keep you from getting stuck.
5. SIG Sauer P365 XL
Plenty of folks buy the standard P365, then end up here once they admit they want a little more grip and a little more shootability. That extra length doesn’t sound like much until you’re 150 rounds into a practice day.
If you’re the type who will actually train, the XL makes it easier to do. It’s still a carry gun, just not a “fight with it because it’s so small” carry gun.
6. Smith & Wesson M&P9 M2.0 Compact
I’ve watched more than one die-hard “I only shoot Glocks” guy quietly end up with one of these. The grip texture is aggressive, and yeah, it can chew up a cover garment. But the gun stays planted, and that matters.
The trigger is good enough, the ergonomics fit a lot of hands, and it’s proven. It’s also one of those pistols that doesn’t need excuses made for it.
7. Smith & Wesson M&P9 Shield Plus
For years the single-stack carry gun was the rite of passage, and a lot of them were honestly miserable to shoot well. The Shield Plus is what a slim carry pistol should’ve been all along: thin, light, and not underpowered on capacity.
It’s a gun you can carry in real life without dressing around it. The best carry gun is the one that actually shows up on your belt.
8. Heckler & Koch VP9
The VP9 is for the shooter who cares how a pistol points and how it feels during a long practice session. It’s comfortable, accurate, and easy to run fast without feeling like you’re wrestling it.
It’s not the cheapest option, and HK fans can be a little intense. Still, the pistol earns its place by being easy to shoot well. That matters more than internet arguments.
9. Heckler & Koch P30
This is the one that sticks around for people who want a hammer-fired gun that’s modern enough to live with. The P30 has a reputation for reliability that isn’t based on marketing.
It’s not the lightest carry option, and the trigger can be an acquired taste depending on the variant. But the build quality is obvious the moment you handle it.
10. Walther PDP Compact
Some pistols feel like they were designed by folks who actually shoot. The PDP is one of them. The grip, the sights, the slide serrations—everything feels like it’s meant to be used with sweaty hands on a hot day.
It’s also a pistol that makes average shooters look a little better than they are. Not magic. Just a good trigger and good ergonomics.
11. CZ 75 SP-01
There’s always one guy at the range who brings an SP-01 and quietly shoots the tightest groups of the day. This pistol is heavier than most modern polymer guns, and that weight is a feature, not a bug.
The recoil impulse is smooth, the gun tracks well, and it rewards good fundamentals. It’s not the easiest thing to conceal, but for training and home use it’s hard to dislike.
12. CZ P-10 C
For shooters who want a striker-fired workhorse but don’t want to be married to one brand, the P-10 C keeps showing up. It’s a solid blend of size, handling, and shootability.
It also tends to be priced in that sweet spot where you can buy the gun and still afford ammo and range time. That’s a bigger deal than another “feature” you’ll never use.
13. Beretta 92FS / M9
This is one of those pistols guys swear they’re going to sell, then don’t. It’s big, it’s dated in spots, and the slide-mounted safety isn’t everyone’s favorite. Still, it’s soft shooting and ridiculously proven.
If you grew up around them, there’s also a familiarity that counts for something. And if you keep decent magazines and springs in it, they can run a long time.
14. Beretta PX4 Storm Compact
The PX4 gets overlooked because it isn’t trendy. Then someone shoots one and realizes it’s one of the smoother compact pistols out there, especially in 9mm.
It’s not as common on shelves, so holster selection can take a little hunting. But for folks who actually care about how a pistol behaves under recoil, this one can be a pleasant surprise.
15. Ruger Mark IV (Standard/22/45)
Every serious shooter eventually buys a .22 pistol again. Not because it’s “fun” (it is), but because it’s the cheapest way to practice sights and trigger without beating yourself up.
The Mark IV’s takedown system is a gift compared to the older designs. It’s also one of the few guns where a brick of ammo and an afternoon can legitimately make you better.
16. Browning Buck Mark
If the Ruger Mark series is the pickup truck of .22 pistols, the Buck Mark is the slightly nicer one that still works every day. They’re accurate, pleasant, and they tend to run well if you keep them reasonably clean.
This is also a pistol that turns into a “forever gun.” Folks buy them for plinking, then realize they’re perfect for training new shooters without frustration.
17. Ruger GP100 (4-inch)
There’s a phase where people act like revolvers are obsolete, then they actually spend time outdoors and realize simple has value. A 4-inch GP100 is not light, but it’s tough, controllable, and easy to live with.
It’s a great “ranch” handgun: something that can ride in a truck, handle neglect better than it should, and still go bang when you need it. There is nothing fancy about it, and that is kind of the point.
18. Smith & Wesson Model 686 (4-inch)
If you like a revolver with a little refinement, the 686 keeps earning its keep. The trigger feel is often what hooks people. It’s the kind of gun that makes you want to slow down and shoot well.
For woods carry, it’s not for everybody, but it’s a confidence gun. When you’ve seen enough finicky semi-autos and magazine issues over the years, that confidence starts to matter.
19. Colt Python (modern production)
Not everyone needs a Python, and plenty of folks never will. But serious shooters who’ve been around the block tend to end up with one because it scratches the “nice revolver” itch in a way most guns don’t.
It’s expensive, and you don’t buy it because it’s the most practical tool. You buy it because it’s a quality piece that’s enjoyable to shoot and worth keeping. Just don’t confuse “collector cool” with “daily beater.”
20. Staccato P
This is the pistol a lot of shooters land on after they’ve bought three or four “almost as good” alternatives and finally admit they want a high-end 2011 that runs. The Staccato P isn’t cheap, and that’s the whole obstacle.
What you get is a gun that shoots flat, points fast, and makes hard shots feel more doable. It’s not necessary for most folks, but serious shooters who train a lot tend to appreciate what it brings. Ask me how I know.
The funny part about this whole pattern is that it doesn’t end with one perfect handgun. It ends with a small, sensible mix: a mid-size 9mm you trust, a carry gun you actually carry, and a .22 you shoot the most. Everything else is just you paying tuition. And most of us have paid it.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Subscribe to our newsletter so you never miss an article.
Here’s more from us:
