Some pistols give you that feeling of trust the moment you pick them up — balanced, predictable, ready to work. Others feel like you’ve strapped a brick to your hip for no real reason. Weight doesn’t always equal reliability, but a lot of heavy pistols pretend it does. You see them at the range or hear them bragged about online — full of steel, nostalgia, and marketing — but the truth shows up when you carry one all day or miss your second shot because of the slow recovery. They might shoot fine, but they don’t inspire much confidence when you’re fumbling with holster weight or trying to clear a jam with a numb hand. These are the handguns that weigh more than their worth, no matter what the catalog or gun counter hero says.
Desert Eagle .50 AE
The Desert Eagle looks like something out of an action movie — and that’s exactly where it belongs. It’s massive, heavy, and wildly impractical for anything outside of pure entertainment. Chambered in .50 AE, it kicks like a mule and feels like you’re swinging a cinder block every time you draw.
It’s one of those guns that turns heads but doesn’t deliver much in the way of practicality or control. Accuracy suffers when your hands are sore, and carrying it feels like lugging around a full-size hammer in your waistband. It’s fun to shoot once or twice, but the novelty wears off as soon as you realize it’s too heavy for carry and too cumbersome for quick follow-ups. It’s not a sidearm — it’s a conversation piece with a trigger.
Smith & Wesson 500
The S&W 500 is legendary for power, but that power comes at the cost of everything else. It’s a monster in both weight and recoil, and unless you’re hunting big game up close, it’s overkill. The stainless frame feels like carrying a small dumbbell, and that long barrel doesn’t do you any favors in the woods or at the range.
You’ll hear people call it “the ultimate revolver,” but most of those folks shoot it twice and put it away. Follow-up shots are slow, accuracy suffers once fatigue sets in, and the recoil can physically hurt inexperienced shooters. It’s impressive, sure — but only in the way holding a live firework is impressive. If confidence comes from control and consistency, this revolver misses both by a mile.
Colt Anaconda
There’s a lot of nostalgia wrapped up in the Colt Anaconda. Big-bore revolvers have always carried a certain mystique, but that doesn’t mean they’re practical. The Anaconda is heavy enough to pull your belt down and long enough to snag on everything between your holster and the brush.
It shoots well, but it’s far from confidence-inspiring when you’re trying to draw quickly or hold steady offhand. The double-action pull feels clunky, and recoil management is an ongoing battle despite all that mass. Colt fans still love it, but most admit it spends more time in the safe than in the field. It’s built beautifully — no denying that — but heavy craftsmanship doesn’t automatically make a revolver trustworthy when things move fast or your hands are shaking.
Beretta 92FS
The Beretta 92FS has been around forever, and it’s earned a reputation for reliability — but it’s also a chunk of metal to carry. For a 9mm, it’s unnecessarily large and heavy, with a slide that seems designed for gym workouts instead of defensive shooting.
It shoots smoothly, but that weight becomes a problem once you’re trying to conceal or carry it daily. The long trigger reach and wide grip make it hard for some shooters to handle confidently, and malfunctions become more common if you limp-wrist under stress. The 92FS does its job, but in today’s world of lighter, more efficient pistols, it feels like a relic. It’s a sidearm that inspires more nostalgia than assurance — solid on the bench, awkward in a holster.
CZ 97B
The CZ 97B is an excellent example of overengineering gone too far. It’s accurate, reliable, and beautifully made — but it’s also enormous. Chambered in .45 ACP, the weight might seem like an advantage for recoil, but it becomes a burden long before you hit the end of a training session.
Its grip is thick and awkward for most shooters, and the heavy slide makes it tough to manipulate quickly. You’ll find yourself shooting slower not because you want to, but because your arms get tired. It’s not that the pistol doesn’t perform — it’s that it demands too much effort for what it delivers. It’s a confidence killer when you’re struggling to draw or hold sight alignment under fatigue. Great gun on paper, but not in practice.
FNX-45 Tactical
The FNX-45 Tactical checks every box for features — threaded barrel, optics-ready, high capacity — and then adds two pounds of weight you never asked for. It’s massive for a polymer pistol, and once you hang a suppressor or optic on it, it turns into a small carbine with a trigger.
Sure, it’s accurate and capable, but it’s hardly something you’d carry without feeling weighed down. The slide sits high, the grip is long, and even with a great trigger, the overall balance feels off. It’s a sidearm that looks tactical and feels like duty-grade equipment — because it is. Problem is, confidence comes from how natural a pistol feels in hand, and this one feels like holding a cordless drill. Functional? Yes. Comfortable? Not even close.
Desert Eagle XIX in .44 Magnum
While slightly tamer than the .50 AE version, the .44 Magnum Desert Eagle still carries the same flaws — heavy, awkward, and far more work than it’s worth. The gas system and massive slide add weight where you don’t need it, and follow-up shots feel like a chore.
Most shooters walk away impressed with the sound, not the performance. It’s not an inaccurate gun, but you can’t shoot it fast or comfortably enough to build real confidence. Drawing it feels like unholstering a brick, and that bulk destroys any thought of concealment. If you’re into collecting conversation pieces, fine — but if you’re chasing a reliable, responsive handgun, you’ll lose faith in it the second your wrists start to ache.
Heckler & Koch Mk23
The Mk23 was designed for military use — and it shows. It’s reliable and accurate, but it’s also absurdly big and heavy. You can’t conceal it, can’t carry it comfortably, and can’t shoot it without feeling like you’re lugging around an entire toolkit.
It’s overbuilt in every sense of the word, and while that sounds tough, it translates to sluggish handling and slow recovery. Confidence comes from control and ease of use, not from owning a gun that looks like it came from a Navy SEAL armory. The Mk23 is one of those pistols you respect, but never bond with. It’s too much gun for most situations, and its size alone makes you question whether it’s worth the effort. Impressive? Absolutely. Practical? Not remotely.
SIG Sauer P220 Stainless Elite
The SIG P220 in stainless steel feels like a well-built piece of machinery — and it is. But that weight works against it once you start carrying or shooting for extended periods. Every ounce is noticeable, and recoil recovery feels sluggish despite the heft.
The pistol’s precision is undeniable, but confidence fades when you realize how slow it is to handle under stress. Drawing and presenting quickly takes real effort, and its large frame doesn’t play nice with smaller hands. You’ll hit what you aim at, but not fast enough to matter in a pinch. It’s a fine pistol for the range or display case, but as a serious carry gun, it’s overbuilt for the job. Heavy steel may look reassuring, but it doesn’t always shoot that way.
Magnum Research BFR
The “Biggest, Finest Revolver” lives up to its name in one way — it’s big. Everything else about it is a stretch. Chambered in rifle calibers like .45-70, it’s not so much a pistol as a handheld artillery piece. The weight borders on absurd, and the recoil is equally punishing.
You won’t find many people carrying it for anything other than novelty. It’s accurate enough if you can control it, but you’ll need wrists like a lumberjack. Confidence isn’t what you feel shooting a BFR — it’s what you lose after the first cylinder. It’s a pistol that dares you to fire it and then makes you regret doing so. Fun? Maybe once. Practical? Never. It belongs in a collection, not a holster.
Desert Eagle L5 Lightweight
The “lightweight” version of the Desert Eagle sounds like an improvement until you realize it’s still heavier than most full-size pistols on the market. The reduced mass does help recoil slightly, but the overall handling remains awkward. The balance feels top-heavy, and it’s far from ergonomic.
You might think you’re getting a more manageable version of a classic powerhouse, but all you’re really doing is trading one kind of discomfort for another. It’s still too bulky for serious carry, still awkward to draw, and still doesn’t inspire the kind of confidence a defensive handgun should. It’s the same old Desert Eagle experience, only marginally lighter — and that’s not saying much. If weight were all it took to make a pistol reliable, this one would be king. Unfortunately, it’s mostly just heavy.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
Calibers That Shouldn’t Even Be On the Shelf Anymore
Rifles That Shouldn’t Be Trusted Past 100 Yards
*This article was developed with AI-powered tools and has been carefully reviewed by our editors.
