Photo credit: Hairy Hands/Youtube
Every gun guy has a few that got away. Not because they were rare museum pieces, either. They got away because the tag on the trigger guard was fair, the gun felt right in the hands, and instead of saying “I’ll take it,” we decided to be responsible and “sleep on it.” Then we came back and stared at an empty spot in the rack.
This isn’t a list of magic guns. It’s a list of real models that show up on used racks, pawn counters, estate tables, and “buddy’s uncle is selling” situations with prices that don’t happen twice. When the numbers line up and the condition is honest, these are the ones I wish I’d grabbed instead of thinking it over.
1. Marlin 336 (JM-stamped)

The old JM-stamped 336 is the kind of deer rifle that disappears the moment a sensible price shows up. It carries flat, points fast, and it balances like it was made for slipping through timber instead of posing on the internet. When you find one that hasn’t been “customized” with a hacksaw and a can of spray paint, you’re already ahead.
What makes the regret sting is how useful it is year after year. A 336 in .30-30 will kill deer clean inside normal woods ranges, feeds slick when it’s not abused, and doesn’t punish you on the bench. Replacement isn’t just about money, either. The newer ones can be fine, but the older fit and finish, the wood-to-metal, and the overall feel are tough to duplicate once you let one walk.
2. Ruger M77 Mark II (controlled-round feed)

I’ve handled a pile of bolt guns that shoot great but feel like appliances. The M77 Mark II isn’t that. It has that controlled-round feed action that just feels serious, and the three-position safety is still one of my favorites for hunting with cold hands and thick gloves.
The deals show up when someone is cleaning out a safe and doesn’t care about internet hype. If the bore is clean and the stock isn’t cracked, you’re buying a rifle that’ll handle rain, dust, and hard knocks without getting dramatic. The regret comes later when you realize you can spend a lot more and not end up with a rifle that’s any more trustworthy in the field.
3. Smith & Wesson Model 19 (pinned and recessed)

There are revolvers that are fun, and then there are revolvers that make you slow down and appreciate what you’re holding. A clean Model 19 with the older pinned-and-recessed features is that kind of gun. The trigger is usually better than it has any right to be, and the balance is about perfect for a belt gun.
Prices on these have a habit of jumping while you’re “doing research.” Yes, you need to be honest about .357 loads and round counts, because some of these guns lived a steady diet of hot stuff. Still, for a woods revolver, trail gun, and just plain pride-of-ownership piece, it’s one I should’ve bought the second I saw a fair tag.
4. Glock 19 Gen 3 (with factory night sights)

I know, boring. But boring is what works when you’re buying a pistol to carry and actually bet your hide on. Gen 3 Glock 19s show up used with honest holster wear, and when the price is right it’s almost silly how hard they are to beat for a do-everything handgun.
The reason I’ve regretted passing on a couple isn’t “collector value.” It’s because mags are everywhere, parts are everywhere, and the platform is as close to plug-and-play reliable as it gets. When you find one that comes with extra mags, decent sights, and a clean internals look, you’re not just buying a pistol. You’re buying into the easiest support system in the handgun world.
5. Remington 870 Wingmaster (older, smooth action)

An older Wingmaster with a slick action is hard not to grin about. You can feel the difference when you rack it. The newer budget 870s can work fine, but the old ones have that polished, broken-in feel that you can’t fake with a weekend of cycling dummy shells.
What hurts is how practical the gun is. It can be a bird gun in the morning and a home-defense shotgun at night with a simple barrel swap, and used barrels aren’t hard to find. When a clean Wingmaster shows up with good bluing and wood that hasn’t been beat to death, that’s the moment to quit thinking and start filling out paperwork.
6. CZ 452 (bolt-action .22 LR)

Every serious shooter eventually learns a good .22 is not a “cheap gun.” A CZ 452 is the kind you keep forever because it makes you look like a better shot than you are, and it does it without being finicky. The little Mauser-style action is smooth, and the accuracy is the sort of thing you notice right away on steel and small targets.
They don’t make the 452 anymore, and that matters. The newer CZ rimfires are good, but the 452 has its own following for a reason. When you see one priced like a generic .22 and not like a “classic,” that’s your sign. It’s a squirrel rifle, a trainer, a range toy, and a confidence builder all in one.
7. Winchester Model 70 (pre-64)

If you’ve ever handled a real pre-64 Model 70, you know why folks get weird about them. The action feels solid without being clunky, and the whole rifle has a “built to last” vibe that’s hard to put into words. Not every one is a tack driver out of the box, but most are plenty accurate for hunting.
The mistake is thinking you’ll see another one at the same money. A lot of them got drilled, refinished, or otherwise “improved,” so an honest one matters. I’ve watched pre-64s get bought while I was still doing the math in my head. That one hurts, because it’s a rifle you can hunt with, hand down, and never have to apologize for owning.
8. Ruger GP100 (4-inch, stainless)

A 4-inch stainless GP100 is not glamorous, and that is exactly why it’s so good. It’s a revolver you can run hard without babying. The weight soaks up recoil, the lockup is stout, and it’s easy to shoot well even when you’re not having your best day.
When they show up used, it’s often because someone decided they were “over revolvers” or wanted something lighter. Fine. That’s when you buy it. The GP100 is a perfect camp gun and a great handgun to keep around the property where snakes, coyotes, and two-legged problems are all possibilities. It’s also one of the easier revolvers to live with long term because you’re not constantly worried about wearing it out.
9. Browning A-Bolt (hunting-weight, clean bore)

The A-Bolt doesn’t get talked about like it used to, which is exactly how good deals happen. They’re light enough to carry all day and still feel like a real rifle, not a flimsy mountain wand. The bolt lift is short and quick, and a lot of them just shoot with basic hunting ammo.
I’ve passed on a couple because I convinced myself I “didn’t need another bolt gun.” Then season rolls around and you remember what matters: a rifle that carries well, feeds right, and puts the first cold shot where it belongs. If you find one that hasn’t been messed with, with rings included and a clean crown, that’s not the time to go home and “think.”
10. SIG Sauer P226 (German or early Exeter)

A well-kept P226 has a feel that’s hard to copy. The slide-to-frame fit, the DA/SA trigger that smooths out with use, and the way it tracks in recoil all add up to a pistol that just runs. When one pops up used, it’s often because the owner wants to simplify to striker-fired guns or fund something shiny.
What I’ve regretted is passing on the ones that came with original mags and weren’t worn out. A lot of police trade-ins look rough but have plenty of life, and the right price makes them a steal. It’s not the lightest carry option, but as a nightstand pistol, range gun, or “one pistol for everything,” it’s tough to beat.
Free for gun owners: If something happened to you tomorrow, would your family know where the guns are, who has the safe combination, or what to do first? Our free Gun Owner’s Family Checklist walks them through it. It takes about 15 minutes to fill out. Get your free copy here.
11. Colt 6920 (plain, no-frills carbine)

There are flashier ARs, and there are cheaper ARs. The Colt 6920 sits in that sweet spot of “known quantity.” When you find one used at a sane price, it’s usually from someone who barely shot it and decided they needed a different hobby. That’s the best kind of used gun.
The regret isn’t about owning a “name.” It’s about having a baseline rifle you can trust and build around if you want, or leave bone-stock and just shoot. Parts compatibility is easy, magazines are everywhere, and the thing tends to just run if you feed it decent ammo and don’t treat it like a shovel. For a working rifle, that simplicity is worth money.
12. Savage 99 (in .300 Savage or .308)

The Savage 99 is one of those rifles that feels like American hunting history you can still take into the woods. The lever action is different than the usual tube-mag guns, and the rotary magazine is a big reason it aged so well. A clean 99 is slim, quick, and has a character you don’t get from modern plastics.
When you find one that isn’t drilled to death, with decent checkering and a good bore, it tends to be underpriced compared to how cool and capable it is. The downside is ammo availability if you’re talking oddball chamberings, so I lean toward .300 Savage or .308. Pass on a nice one and you’ll spend a long time trying to “replace” it with something that doesn’t scratch the same itch.
13. Mossberg 590A1 (heavy-walled barrel)

The 590A1 is not a dainty shotgun. It’s built like it expects to be dropped in the gravel and still get cycled hard. The heavier barrel and robust build make it a favorite for folks who want a shotgun that’s more tool than trophy.
When one shows up used with the right price, it’s often because it’s “too heavy” or “kicks too much.” Those are fair complaints, especially with buckshot. But for a home-defense shotgun that won’t get babied, or a truck gun that lives behind a seat (stored safely and legally, obviously), it’s a smart buy. Accessories and parts are easy, and the tang safety is still one of the most natural shotgun safeties out there.
14. Ruger 10/22 (older, walnut stock)

Everybody has seen a 10/22, which is why it’s easy to walk past one without thinking. The older walnut-stock rifles at a good price are the ones I wish I’d grabbed. They have that simple, classic look, and they still do everything a .22 semi-auto needs to do on a farm or at a range.
Sure, you can buy new 10/22s all day long. But the older ones with decent wood and no weird mods just feel right, and they tend to run if you keep them reasonably clean. The bigger point is utility: cheap practice, small game, pest control around outbuildings, and teaching new shooters without scaring them. When a clean one comes with a couple rotary mags and a decent scope, that’s a complete package.
15. Beretta 92FS (Italian-made)

Holding a 92FS that hasn’t been abused is a reminder that full-size pistols can be pleasant. The grip is big, yes, but the gun shoots soft, tracks well, and eats ammo without being temperamental. When they’re priced right, they’re one of the best “buy once, cry never” pistols for the money.
I’ve seen Italian-made examples at prices that didn’t match what they were, usually because somebody wanted to chase the newest compact wonder-nine. I get it. But if you want a range pistol that doesn’t beat you up, a bedside gun with mild recoil, and something that’s been proven for decades, the 92FS is hard to argue with. Magazines are easy, holsters are everywhere, and the gun has a way of making average shooters look steady.
16. Tikka T3 (Lite model, common caliber)

The Tikka T3 Lite is one of those rifles that makes you question why you ever tolerated gritty bolts and mediocre triggers. They tend to be accurate right out of the box, the action is smooth, and the factory trigger usually needs little or nothing. For a hunter, that’s a big deal, because most shots are one cold shot, not a five-shot group.
The regret comes from passing on used ones in .308, .270, or .30-06 that were priced like “just another bolt gun.” They aren’t. They’re light enough to carry up ridges, and they don’t feel like they’re going to fall apart if you bump them on a tree stand ladder. Are they plain-looking? Yep. But the first time you hike all day with one and then shoot straight at dusk, you stop caring about plain.
17. Smith & Wesson Model 36 (Chief’s Special)

A little Model 36 is easy to underestimate until you spend time actually carrying one. It’s slim, it tucks away nicely, and the shape just works. When you find an older one with a decent finish and a tight cylinder, it’s a classy revolver that still has a purpose.
These show up when somebody inherits one and doesn’t want a revolver, or when a collector is thinning out. The price can be surprisingly fair if the shop doesn’t get hung up on the nostalgia factor. What I wish I’d done is buy the clean ones with original grips instead of assuming they’d always be around. J-frames aren’t for everybody, and they take practice, but they’re comforting in a pocket or on an ankle in a way bigger guns aren’t.
18. SKS (Norinco or Yugoslav, un-bubba’d)

Once upon a time, SKSs were stacked like cordwood at prices you’d laugh about now. Those days are gone, and the unmodified rifles are getting harder to find because so many got plastic stocks, cheap scopes, and other “upgrades” that made them worse. An honest SKS with wood furniture and a clean bore is a practical rifle with real history.
It’s not a precision gun, and it’s not light. But it’s generally reliable, easy to feed, and it’ll handle rough weather if you treat it like the simple rifle it is. The real reason to buy when the price is right is that it’s a great “loaner rifle” for a buddy at deer camp (where legal), a truck-and-farm utility rifle, and a range gun that’s just fun. The longer you wait, the more you pay for one that hasn’t been messed with.
19. Colt Python (older production)

The Python is one of those guns that even non-revolver people stop and stare at. The lockup, the finish, the way the trigger stacks—when you handle a good one, you understand why it became a thing. It’s also the kind of purchase you talk yourself out of because it feels indulgent.
Here’s the problem: “thinking it over” is how you end up watching the price climb out of reach. I’m not saying a Python is the best working woods revolver. It’s not. It’s a nicer, more refined tool than most of us need, and you don’t buy it to neglect it. But as a piece that holds value, scratches the craftsmanship itch, and still shoots wonderfully with reasonable .38 and .357 loads, it’s a regret when you find one priced like a used revolver and let it go.
20. Remington Model 700 (older ADL/BDL, before the drama)

The Model 700 has had its share of noise over the years, and I’m not here to relitigate the internet. What I will say is the older ADL and BDL rifles, especially the ones that haven’t been kitchen-table “accurized,” can be excellent hunting rifles. They often have good barrels, decent triggers (or at least workable ones), and they carry well.
When a clean older 700 shows up with a simple scope, honest wear, and a price that reflects “used deer rifle,” it’s usually a smart buy. The aftermarket support is huge, so you can keep it stock or set it up to fit you better without doing anything sketchy. The regret comes when you pass on a solid, boring rifle and then realize later that boring is exactly what you want when you’re cold, tired, and trying to make one good shot count.
Every one of these has a reason someone didn’t keep it. Too heavy, too plain, too old-school, too “not my style anymore.” That’s fine. The trick is recognizing the moment when a fair price and a useful gun cross paths. If you handle it and your gut says it’s right, don’t overthink yourself into an empty rack spot. Ask me how I know.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Subscribe to our newsletter so you never miss an article.
Here’s more from us:

