Photo credit: 1957Shep/YouTube
I’ve bought a few things over the years that were supposed to be “smart money.” Most of them weren’t. Meanwhile, the shotguns in the back of the safe just keep chugging along, and when I glance at used prices—especially on clean examples—I realize a lot of these scatterguns didn’t just hold up in the field. They held up on the wallet side too.
I’m not saying shotguns are some secret retirement plan. I’m saying the right models stay useful, stay desirable, and don’t get replaced easily once you let them go. Some are classics, some are workhorses, and a few are oddballs that suddenly got hard to find. Here are 20 that tend to keep their footing better than most gear, and better than plenty of “investments” I’ve tried.
1. Remington 870 Wingmaster
The older Wingmasters have a feel you don’t have to explain to anyone who’s run one. The action is slick, the steel and walnut carry right, and they point like they were fitted instead of assembled. I’ve seen plenty of them with honest field wear that still lock up tight and cycle like they mean it.
When someone sells one thinking they’ll “upgrade,” it usually turns into a long hunt for a clean replacement at a price that doesn’t sting. There are a lot of 870s out there, sure, but nice Wingmasters don’t sit on racks long.
2. Remington 870 Police Magnum
This one is less about pretty and more about built-for-duty parts and simple toughness. The Police Magnums I’ve handled tend to feel tighter and more deliberate than the average used pump that’s lived a hard life. They’re boring in the best way.
Parts, barrels, and accessories are everywhere, and that keeps them relevant. If you find one that hasn’t been “improved” by somebody with a Dremel and a dream, they tend to keep value and move fast.
3. Mossberg 500 (older U.S.-made models)
There’s nothing fancy about the 500, and that is kind of the point. Safety on top where it belongs for a lot of hunters, twin action bars, and it runs when it’s wet, cold, and full of cattail fuzz. I’ve watched these get passed around families like a good chainsaw.
The older ones with decent fit and finish don’t seem to get cheaper anymore. You can still buy a new one, but the used market likes the proven older guns that haven’t been messed with.
4. Mossberg 590A1
Yes, it’s heavier. Yes, it’s not the first gun I grab for walking miles behind a bird dog. But for a “do it all” defensive/utility shotgun that takes abuse, the 590A1 has a reputation that keeps it from getting bargain-bin cheap.
The ghost ring versions especially tend to stay in demand. Folks like the idea of a shotgun that’s built like it expects to be dropped, banged, and still work.
5. Benelli M4
If you’ve ever shot an M4 side-by-side with other semiautos, you get it. It’s soft enough for what it is, cycles the good stuff reliably, and it feels like a serious tool. It’s also one of those guns people talk themselves out of because of sticker shock, then regret it later.
They don’t flood the used market, and when they do, they rarely sit long. It’s not hype when a platform stays popular for years and years without needing a redesign.
6. Benelli Super Black Eagle (SBE, all generations)
Waterfowlers can be hard on gear, and the SBE line has been riding in muddy boats and layout blinds for a long time. They’re light enough to carry, hit hard, and they keep running if you treat them halfway decent. The “feel” is very Benelli—fast, a little snappy, but dependable.
Even older SBEs hold attention because they’re still relevant in a blind. When a shotgun keeps killing geese and still fits modern loads and chokes, it doesn’t become obsolete.
7. Beretta 686 Silver Pigeon I
There’s a reason you see 686s everywhere from sporting clays to bird camps. They balance well, the actions hold up, and Beretta knows how to build an over/under that doesn’t feel like a 2×4 with triggers. This is one of the safer “buy once, cry once” guns out there.
They also have that nice middle ground: respectable without being so fancy you’re scared to scratch it. Used prices stay surprisingly firm on clean examples.
8. Browning Citori (any of the proven field grades)
I’ve heard guys complain a Citori is “too heavy” right up until they shoot it. The weight is part of why they swing smooth and don’t beat you up. They’re not delicate guns, and a well-kept Citori can live a very long life.
What keeps value strong is simple: they’re trusted. If you’re standing at a gun counter looking at used over/unders, a Citori is the one nobody is scared to buy.
9. Browning A5 (Belgian-made Auto-5)
The old humpback is not for everyone. They recoil different, they have their own quirks, and they’re not as “slick” as modern gas guns. Still, there’s a reason people light up when they see a Belgian A5 in good shape.
Collectibility matters here, but so does function. Plenty of these are still hunting every fall, and the ones that haven’t been refinished into oblivion keep creeping upward in value.
10. Browning BPS
Bottom ejection is one of those features you don’t appreciate until you hunt in nasty weather or you’re trying not to pelt your buddy with hulls. The BPS is also built solid and tends to feel more “finished” than some pumps in its price class.
They’re not the trendiest shotgun on the internet, but they stay desirable in the real world. Especially for lefties, a clean BPS is the kind of gun that quietly sells itself.
11. Ithaca 37 (older slam-fire capable models)
The Ithaca 37 has a cult following for a reason: it carries slim, points quick, and bottom ejection keeps the receiver cleaner than you’d expect. The action can feel like it’s on rails when it’s right. It’s a classic upland pump that doesn’t need to apologize to anyone.
Older examples with good barrels and honest condition have been trending up, not down. You can still find them, but not for the “grandpa’s old beater” prices folks expect.
12. Winchester Model 12
Ask any old bird hunter about the Model 12 and you’ll get a story. They’re smooth, they’re strong, and they have that old-school machining you can feel in your hands. They also tend to be tighter than you’d think, even after decades.
The downside is parts and work can take a little more effort than modern pumps. But that’s also part of why the good ones don’t get cheap—folks who own nice Model 12s usually hang onto them.
13. Winchester Model 1897
This one is part history and part pure mechanical charm. They’re not the shotgun I’d hand a new shooter, and they’re not as “practical” as an 870. But they have presence, and they’re flat-out fun for the right owner.
Values can swing depending on condition and originality, but the overall trend has been strong. Try replacing one later, especially a solid original with a good bore. That one hurts.
14. Franchi Affinity 3
Franchi figured out a sweet spot with the Affinity: light, simple, reliable, and it doesn’t cost like the high-end Italian flagships. It’s a gun that gets carried a lot, and carried guns that run well tend to earn loyalty.
Used ones don’t hang around long because they’re a known quantity. When a shotgun has a reputation for “just working” with minimal fuss, it holds value in a hurry.
15. Beretta A300 Ultima
The A300 line has become a go-to for folks who actually shoot a lot but don’t want to baby their gun. It’s a gas gun that runs clean enough, soft enough, and it fits a wide range of shooters without drama. For the money, it’s hard to argue with.
What keeps the resale strong is that it solves real problems: recoil, reliability, and decent fit out of the box. If you find one used at a fair price, it usually means you need to decide fast.
16. Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus
This is a “hard use” waterfowl gun that’s priced like one, and it performs like one. It’s soft shooting for 3.5-inch capability, it cycles well, and it’s built for ugly conditions. If you’ve ever tried to chip ice out of a shotgun action at daylight, you get why this matters.
They’re expensive new, so used buyers circle them when they appear. You don’t see a lot of panic selling on these because the guys who buy them usually had a reason.
17. Benelli Nova
The Nova is not a pretty shotgun. It’s bulky, and the forend can feel like it was designed by someone wearing winter gloves—which, honestly, it probably was. But it’s one of the toughest budget-ish pumps ever made.
I’ve watched Novas live behind truck seats and in damp camp closets and still show up opening morning ready to go. That reputation props up resale even when the finish has some scars.
18. Stoeger M3000
The M3000 is a working man’s inertia gun, and it’s earned its place. It’s not a boutique shotgun, and some need a little break-in with heavier loads. Still, a good one runs, and it gets folks into an inertia system without a top-shelf price tag.
Because they’re so common in the turkey and waterfowl crowd, used parts and knowledge are everywhere. That keeps demand steady, which keeps values steadier than you’d expect for a “budget” semiauto.
19. CZ Bobwhite G2
Side-by-sides aren’t everybody’s cup of coffee, but the Bobwhite G2 has pulled a lot of folks into the double-gun world without requiring a second mortgage. It’s simple, it carries well, and it has that upland vibe that makes you want to walk just a little slower and listen for wings.
They’ve gotten more popular as hunters rediscover light, fast-handling guns for quail and rabbits. Popularity matters, and these have it right now.
20. Ruger Red Label
The Red Label has had an up-and-down reputation depending on the era and the specific gun, and I’m not going to pretend every one is a magical unicorn. But Ruger doesn’t make them like they used to, and that alone changes the conversation.
A clean Red Label with the right barrel length and a solid lockup tends to get attention fast. It’s one of those shotguns that quietly moved from “used over/under” into “harder to replace than you think.”
If you’re staring at the safe trying to decide what stays and what goes, I’d slow down before cutting loose any of these just to fund the next new thing. The best ones aren’t always the fanciest. They’re the guns that still work when it’s cold, wet, and you’re tired—and they’re the ones you can actually sell quickly if life forces your hand. That kind of value is hard to beat.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
