Photo credit: GunBroker
Every gun guy has played this game. Somebody says, “Here’s the money. You only get one.” And suddenly you realize how many “good deals” you’ve chased that didn’t stay good once the new wore off.
So I’m going to do it straight: 20 guns I’d buy if I got handed a budget and told to spend it on one firearm. Not because they’re trendy, but because they’ve got the kind of usefulness that shows up on a rainy Tuesday, not just on a sunny range day. I’m mixing carry, hunting, and do-it-all guns—because real life doesn’t stick to one lane.
1. Glock 19 (Gen 5)
If you told me I could only have one handgun that covers the most ground, I’d start here. It’s not exciting. It’s not classy. It’s just hard to beat for a gun that carries well, shoots well, and has parts and magazines everywhere.
The Gen 5 is boring in all the right ways: good trigger compared to older ones, no finger grooves, and it runs. You can set it up for carry or keep it plain for home duty, and either way it’s still a Glock 19.
2. Smith & Wesson M&P 2.0 Compact (9mm)
This is the “I like Glocks but not really” pick, and I get it. The grip texture and the way it points feels more natural to a lot of shooters, especially folks who never fully warmed up to the Glock angle.
It’s also a pistol you can actually train with without feeling like you’re fighting it. Mags aren’t hard to find, holster support is solid, and the gun holds up to real use.
3. SIG Sauer P365 XL
For concealed carry, this one hit the sweet spot for a lot of people: thin enough to carry, big enough to shoot. The XL gives you a little more grip and sight radius, and that matters when you’re trying to make hits without rushing.
I like that it doesn’t feel like a “compromise gun” the way some micro-compacts do. Still, it’s small. You’ll feel it more than a compact pistol during long practice sessions, but it’s easier to live with day to day.
4. Ruger SP101 (3-inch, .357 Magnum)
There’s something about a sturdy little revolver that still makes sense out in the sticks. The SP101 isn’t light, and that’s a compliment. It rides in a chest rig, a coat pocket, a pack—wherever—and it doesn’t care about lint, mud, or neglect the way some folks do.
The 3-inch version balances well and gives you a little more velocity and sight radius. Run .38s for practice and step up to .357 when you need it. Simple, dependable.
5. Ruger GP100 (4-inch, .357 Magnum)
If the SP101 is the working man’s revolver, the GP100 is the foreman. It’s heavier, steadier, and easier to shoot well, especially with full-power loads.
This is the revolver I’d want on a property where coyotes show up close, feral dogs are a possibility, or you just want a handgun that feels like it was built for real use. It’s not a “safe queen” gun, and that’s the point.
6. Beretta 92FS
Some guns are like an old pickup: not perfect, but the controls are familiar and the ride is smooth. The 92FS is big, sure. But it’s also one of the softer-shooting 9mms you can run fast, and that matters if you actually practice.
I’ve watched new shooters do better with a Beretta than with smaller polymer pistols, simply because it’s stable in the hands. If it fits your carry style, great. If not, it still makes an excellent home pistol.
7. Colt Python (4-inch, .357 Magnum)
This isn’t the “most practical” revolver on the list, but if I’m handed money and told to pick one, I’m not pretending emotion doesn’t matter. A Python is one of those guns you don’t forget the first time you handle it. The action and balance are just right.
It’s also a gun that makes you want to shoot better. Not everyone needs that, but it’s nice to own something that’s both usable and a little special.
8. Ruger 10/22 Carbine
If you’ve ever tried to keep kids interested in shooting, or you’ve wanted a low-cost way to stay sharp, you already know. A 10/22 is the most useful rimfire rifle for normal folks. Cheap ammo, easy handling, and it just works.
The best part is how modular it is without needing to be complicated. You can keep it plain and it still earns its spot. You can also tinker forever. Ask me how I know.
9. Marlin 1895 SBL (.45-70 Government)
This one is for the “thick stuff” crowd. A lever gun that cycles smooth and hits like a hammer has a certain kind of appeal when you hunt timber, river bottoms, and places where shots are close and fast.
.45-70 ammo isn’t cheap, and recoil isn’t polite. Still, there’s a reason these rifles don’t sit long when they show up used. They carry well, point naturally, and they do exactly what you think they’ll do.
10. Henry Big Boy X Model (.357 Magnum)
Lever guns in pistol calibers are pure practicality disguised as fun. A .357 lever rifle is easy to feed, easy to shoot, and surprisingly capable for deer inside reasonable distances with the right load and good shot placement.
The X Model brings a more modern setup without turning it into a gimmick. It’s a handy woods rifle that you’ll actually grab, not just admire.
11. Remington 870 Police Magnum
There are a lot of 870s out there, and not all of them feel the same. The Police Magnum versions tend to have that smoother, tighter “this was built to run” feel. If you’ve cycled a good one, you know.
A pump shotgun is still a smart tool for home and property defense, and it’s hard to beat for versatility. Bird hunting, small game, buckshot, slugs—one gun can cover a lot.
12. Mossberg 590A1
If you want a shotgun that looks like it could survive being used as a canoe paddle, the 590A1 is it. It’s not refined, but it’s durable, and the tang safety is a real plus for a lot of shooters.
It’s also one of those guns that’s easy to keep running because parts and support are everywhere. A good pump gun is never a bad idea when you’ve got one purchase to make.
13. Benelli M2
This is where “nice” starts to show up without being fragile. The M2 runs clean for a semi-auto, cycles a wide range of loads, and it’s lighter than some of the other options that get recommended online.
If you hunt birds, shoot clays, and want a shotgun that can do a little bit of everything, the M2 makes sense. It’s not cheap, but it’s also not the kind of purchase you regret after the first season.
14. Browning A5 (Sweet Sixteen)
The 16 gauge isn’t dead, it’s just picky about who it belongs to. The Sweet Sixteen carries like a dream, and for upland hunting it hits a balance that’s hard to describe until you’ve walked miles with one.
Is it necessary? No. Is it a gun I’d buy if I could only pick one and wanted something that makes me look forward to opening day? Absolutely.
15. Tikka T3x Lite
If you’re trying to buy one rifle to hunt almost anything in North America (within reason), a .308 in a good bolt gun is hard to argue with. The Tikka has a smooth action, good factory trigger, and it’s typically accurate without drama.
It also carries well. That matters more than folks admit after they’ve hauled a heavy rifle up and down ridges all week. A Tikka is a “work rifle” that still feels nice.
16. Ruger American Rifle (6.5 Creedmoor)
Not everyone wants to spend premium money, even if they’ve got it. The Ruger American is one of those rifles that can be a little plain, sometimes a little rough, but it flat-out works.
In 6.5 Creedmoor it’s easy to shoot, easy to get accurate with, and ammo is widely available. It’s the kind of rifle that makes you realize you didn’t need to overthink it.
17. Winchester Model 70 (Featherweight)
The .30-06 is still the old reliable for a reason. Put it in a Model 70 Featherweight and you’ve got a rifle that carries like a hunting rifle should, points naturally, and has a safety and action that generations of hunters trust.
This is a “buy once, keep forever” rifle. It doesn’t need to be trendy. It needs to put meat in the freezer for the next twenty years.
18. CZ 457 Varmint (.22 LR)
If you like shooting small groups and you don’t want the rifle to be the limiting factor, the CZ 457 is a great place to land. The fit and finish is there, the action is smooth, and it’s easy to tune with ammo selection.
This is the rimfire that turns an ordinary afternoon into a real practice session. It’s also a small-game rifle that makes careful shots feel easy.
19. Daniel Defense DDM4 V7 (5.56 NATO)
A solid AR-15 is one of the most useful rifles an outdoorsman can own for training, property defense, and general shooting. The DDM4 V7 isn’t the cheapest route, but it’s a known quantity. Reliable, accurate enough, and built with quality parts.
Magazines and ammo are everywhere, recoil is mild, and it’s easy to set up with a good sling and optic without turning it into a science project.
20. Springfield Armory M1A Scout Squad (.308 Winchester)
I know, I know. It’s heavier than it needs to be and not everyone wants to feed a .308 semi-auto. But the Scout Squad version is handy for what it is, and it scratches that “real rifle” itch in a way a lot of modern guns don’t.
It’s not the most efficient option on paper. In the field, it carries fine with a good sling, it’s capable, and it’s the kind of rifle you’ll still want to shoot after the novelty wears off.
If I had to boil this down, it’s simple: I’d spend the budget on a gun that gets used. The one that rides in the truck when you’re checking fence, the one that gets pulled out when a neighbor wants to sight in before season, the one you trust when things feel a little off. Fancy is fine, but useful is better.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
