You think you’ve got a decent rifle, load, and setup — but then it ghosts your consistency. One target shows tight groups, the next? Shell splatter. That’s not you slipping; that’s the rifle. These are the ones that wander when you want them steady, that force you to tweak sight, ammo, bedding, or hold every session. They make you question fundamentals when the truth is the tool. Below are rifles that earn a reputation for inconsistency—guns that refuse to land two shots in the same spot without a fight. If you’ve chased POI shifts and “flyers” that weren’t really flyers, you already know how this feels.
Winchester Model 70 XTR (push‑feed era)
The push‑feed Model 70 XTR generation did fine for many, but a number of shooters report that individual rifles don’t maintain consistent locking behavior. The bolt lug alignment, headspace, and bedding tolerances in some units allow slight shifts in cartridge alignment under recoil. Those tiny variables add up: one shot goes center, next sits an inch off.
Even with premium rings and glass, you’ll find yourself retesting after each string. The action doesn’t always return to the same dimension. That’s why many long-range hunters prefer the older controlled-round-feed versions. The XTR is capable, but it doesn’t guarantee consistency on every rifle. If you bring one to the line, don’t assume it’ll stack—assume it’ll wander unless everything’s perfect.
Remington Model 742 Woodsmaster
Yes, it appears again, because it’s one of those rifles with a grinding history. Accuracy with the 742 often varies over time or across shot strings. Its semi-auto action flexes and wears, the bolt rails loosen, and chamber tolerances shift, leading to point-of-impact drift.
You might get good groups early, but after a few dozen rounds, expect vertical spread or side-to-side movement. The 742’s charm is reliability—but not predictability. Many folks sold theirs after fighting that inconsistency. It’s a rifle you might enjoy for day hunts, but don’t expect repeat precision on steel every time.
Browning BAR Safari
The BAR Safari is smooth, fast, and heavy—but it’s also guilty of consistency slips under stress. It’s a semi-auto, so each shot adds variables: gas pressure changes, action flex, and recoil impulse interplay with bedding and mount stability. In some rifles, that leads to point-of-impact shifts between strings.
You might experience one 3-shot group that’s tight, then see your subsequent shots drift up or left. The trigger push feels clean, so shooters often shake their heads. But when you see your own rifle fail to land two shots in the same spot, it’s humbling. The BAR Safari is lovely in many ways—but in terms of locking down consistency, some examples fall short of expectations.
Marlin Model 336 (post‑Remington)
The 336 is legendary, but during certain production runs (especially in the Remington‑era), accuracy consistency suffered. Lot-to-lot barrel variance and loose chambering tolerances caused rifles to deviate between strings. One barrel might favor certain bullet weights better than others, and point of impact can shift after warming.
Shoot a cold barrel and it might group—heat it with a few rounds and you’ll find your point moved. That erratic behavior reveals itself mostly in longer strings or changing conditions. You might swear your scope or hand changed, but the rifle is often to blame. The Model 336 is practical, durable—but not naturally stable in every specimen. You’ll test several to find one that “believes” your aiming.
Savage Axis (early generation)
The early Savage Axis rifles frequently came with soft bedding or minimal sub‑radiused action shoulders. That allowed subtle shifts when you pulled the shot. Many Axis owners report that their rifles would shoot tight groups once or twice—and then drift later in the session.
You’ll find yourself shifting torque on screws, adjusting cheek weld, and retightening scope mounts just to recover a group. It’s one of those rifles where consistency almost feels accidental. The Axis can be serviceable, but unless you treat it like a custom work project, it won’t keep putting holes in the same place. For a factory budget rifle, that’s disappointing but expected.
Ruger American Rifle (early production)
Some first-run Ruger Americans had bedding and stock fit issues that led to inconsistent harmonics. The harmonic node can shift depending on how the stock contacts the barrel or action. One batch might group well; another will wander shot to shot.
You’ll notice that your zero drifts after firing several magazines. Even trying to reload the same load, the POI might shift. The design is solid, but in execution some rifles didn’t live up to the promise of “American accuracy.” Many owners polish, bed, or glass bed these rifles just to stabilize them. If you carry one, expect to spend extra time testing before trusting it.
Mossberg Patriot (first gen)
The first-gen Patriots had variable chamber finish, inconsistent barrel harmonics, and sometimes sloppy stock fit. That combination contributed to point-of-impact shifts, especially as the barrel heated or with different bullet lots. One group might land, the next will wander.
You’ll find setup changes affect POI more than your hold does. Many users swapped barrels or reworked bedding to tame the wandering. The Patriot’s value is appealing, but its consistency is often installment-based: tweak, test, tweak, test again. It’s not a rifle that hits the same plate twice without your help.
Tikka T3 (early models)
Even a Tikka T3 can behave like an inconsistent shooter under certain conditions. Early models sometimes had nonuniform barrel bedding or slight alignment issues between receiver and stock. That allows different stress states shot to shot, and you’ll see POI drift.
One magazine might group beautifully, then subsequent magazines shift without warning. The variance often appears in hot barrels or with mismatched ammo. You’ll live in a world of retesting and adjustment. It’s a wonderful rifle in many respects, but don’t assume flawless precision on every example. The T3 is too well respected for its misses to be ignored.
Savage 110 Long Range Hunter
The Long Range Hunter is designed for precision, but some rifles display shot-to-shot variance due to heavy barrel heating, torque changes, and insufficient support over long strings. Once the barrel warms, point-of-impact can shift up or left unexpectedly.
You might think that’s normal; to a degree it is. But some examples exhibit variance far beyond expected. Only certain intervals between shots, cool-down periods, or spacing of magazines produce repeatability. That’s when accuracy becomes part science experiment. For a rifle billed for “long range,” that kind of shift is frustrating. You expect consistency, and when a gun doesn’t deliver it reliably, it reminds you how much precision costs in practice.
Remington Model 7
The Model 7 is compact and light, but some versions suffer from harmonics and action bedding instability. Because the action is shorter and lighter, shot-to-shot variance can become more apparent. Even a little torque shift or hand pressure change can move the trajectory.
You’ll see deviation between magazines, or after slight heating. The lightness that makes the Model 7 fun to carry also works against consistency. The POI doesn’t always stay fixed — it dances. It’s a fine rifle for close-up work, but if you expect it to punch the same hole again and again—think twice. Some will do so; many won’t.
Weatherby Vanguard (some production runs)
Weatherby has many solid rifles, but certain Vanguard runs had variable tolerances, barrel to action fit issues, or stock flex under recoil. Those create situations where the rifle itself shifts behavior between strings. You may print tight groups early and later see spreading.
Changing temperatures, reload spacing, or barrel heat can cause the shifts you see. Some owners rebed or ported to stabilize performance. The Vanguard can shoot well—but consistency varies by specimen. Don’t let the brand name fool you. You’ll test a few before you find one that reliably hits the same plate twice.
Like The Avid Outdoorsman’s content? Be sure to follow us.
Here’s more from us:
Calibers That Shouldn’t Even Be On the Shelf Anymore
Rifles That Shouldn’t Be Trusted Past 100 Yards
*This article was developed with AI-powered tools and has been carefully reviewed by our editors.
