The 20 Modern Revolvers That Shame Everything Old-School Smith and Wesson Built

Photo credit: TaurusUSA/Youtube

Walk into any gun shop on a Saturday and you’ll hear it: somebody leaning on the counter talking about “the good old days” of blued steel, walnut, and a certain Massachusetts rollmark like it’s the only way a revolver should be made. I get it. Classic wheelguns have soul.

But out on a cold range bench with wet hands, or riding in a chest rig while you’re cutting fence line, “soul” doesn’t mean much if the sights are hard to see, the trigger stacks weird, or the gun beats itself loose on heavy loads. Modern revolvers have fixed a lot of the stuff we used to just tolerate. Here are 20 current-production (or still-common modern) revolvers that flat-out outperform many of the older patterns folks romanticize.

1. Ruger GP100

The GP100 is what you buy when you’re tired of babying a revolver. The lockwork is robust, the frame is beefy, and it soaks up .357 like it’s supposed to. You can run it hard, clean it when you get to it, and it keeps timing like it didn’t notice.

It’s not dainty, and it’s not trying to be. The grip shape and weight make it one of the easiest full-size .357s to actually shoot well for a full box, not just five “confidence rounds.” If you want a revolver you can hand to a new shooter without flinches and drama, this is a strong start.

2. Ruger SP101

Small revolvers are where older designs can get real unforgiving. The SP101 is still small, still packs easy, but it’s built like a little anvil. That extra mass compared to featherweight snubs makes a difference when you touch off real .357 loads.

The factory trigger can be a little stiff, but it slicks up with use and basic tuning from a competent smith. In a belt holster while you’re working around the property, it carries like a tool, not a collector piece. There is nothing fancy about it, and that is kind of the point.

3. Ruger LCR (in .38 Special +P)

The LCR is ugly to traditionalists, and I don’t care. The cam-style trigger is smooth for what it is, and the gun is light enough that you’ll actually carry it. For a true pocket revolver, that matters more than polished bluing.

Recoil with +P is snappy, no way around it, but the grip design helps keep it manageable. As a “go check the back forty” gun, it disappears and doesn’t drag your pants down. Ask me how I know.

4. Ruger LCRx (3-inch)

Add the exposed hammer and a longer sight radius, and the LCRx turns from last-ditch to legitimately useful. The 3-inch version points well and gives you a better chance of making clean hits on small targets without feeling like you’re balancing a bar of soap.

It’s a practical trail revolver for folks who like the idea of a revolver but hate carrying a brick. You can still run it double-action, but single-action is there if you’re taking a careful shot on a critter in the barn lot.

5. Ruger Super Redhawk (Alaskan)

If your world includes bears, or you’re the guy everyone calls when there’s “something big” in the chicken yard, the Alaskan is built for that job. Short barrel, heavy frame, serious cylinder. It’s not pretty. It’s serious.

The big advantage over many older big-bores is how much abuse it will take without loosening up. Full-house .44 Magnum and heavier options are punishing no matter what, but the Super Redhawk family is designed around living with that reality.

6. Ruger Redhawk (.45 Colt/.45 ACP)

The convertible-cylinder concept isn’t new, but Ruger made it work in a way that feels like it was meant to be used. Being able to shoot .45 ACP in moon clips for easy reloads, then swap to .45 Colt for woods loads, is real-world convenient.

It’s a big revolver, sure, but it carries well in a chest rig and shoots flatter than folks expect. And it’s the kind of gun that won’t make you nervous when a buddy asks, “Mind if I try a few?”

7. Ruger Blackhawk (New Model)

Single-actions aren’t for everybody, but the modern New Model safety system makes them more practical for day-to-day carry than the old-style “five beans in the wheel” routine. For hunting-sidearm duty, a Blackhawk in .357, .41, or .45 Colt still makes a lot of sense.

The accuracy is often better than the shooter deserves, and the platform handles stout loads without feeling fragile. It’s also one of the easiest revolvers to live with in rough weather, because there’s just not much to fuss over.

8. Ruger Wrangler

The Wrangler is a cheap .22, and that’s exactly why it’s good. It’s the revolver you toss in a tackle bag, keep behind the truck seat (secured, of course), or hand to a kid for first-range lessons without sweating every scratch.

Old-school .22 revolvers can be great, but a lot of them are either too precious or too worn. The Wrangler shoots, the sights are usable, and it’s the kind of gun that gets used instead of admired.

9. Ruger New Vaquero

The New Vaquero looks traditional, but it’s built with modern manufacturing and a more carry-friendly size than some of the old tanks. It points naturally and balances well, which matters more than any argument about “real cowboy guns.”

For ranch carry, it’s hard to beat a simple fixed-sight single-action that won’t snag on everything. It’s not a precision target piece, but it’s consistent, and that’s what you need in a working revolver.

10. Colt Python (new production)

Here’s the truth: the new Python isn’t your granddad’s safe queen, and that’s good. The updated internals are built to handle modern shooting habits, meaning you can actually run the thing without treating it like a museum piece.

The trigger is excellent, the fit is solid, and the sights are easy to track. It’s expensive, and you’ll feel it in the wallet. Still, for a premium .357 that’s meant to be shot, it earns its reputation the honest way.

11. Colt King Cobra (3-inch)

The 3-inch King Cobra is one of those revolvers that makes you wonder why this format ever went out of style. It’s compact enough to carry, long enough to shoot, and it balances right where it should.

For a defensive revolver that doesn’t feel like a compromise, this is a strong pick. The sights are better than the old “trench and ramp” setup, and the frame can take real shooting without feeling delicate.

12. Kimber K6s (2-inch)

Six rounds in a snub-nose .357 is a big deal, and the K6s pulled it off without making the gun feel like a brick. The cylinder is surprisingly compact, and the gun carries flatter than you’d think.

It’s a shooter’s revolver more than a nostalgia piece. The trigger is usually good out of the box, and the sights on many variants are actually visible in poor light. That alone shames a lot of older snubs that are basically point-and-hope.

13. Kimber K6s DASA (4-inch)

This one is for folks who want revolver simplicity but like modern control options. The DASA gives you a different manual of arms than most wheelguns, and it’s not everyone’s cup of coffee.

But as a range gun and home-defense revolver, it makes sense. You get the durability and reliability of a revolver with a more contemporary approach to trigger management, and the 4-inch barrel makes it easy to shoot accurately.

14. Chiappa Rhino 60DS

The Rhino looks like something from a sci-fi movie until you shoot it. The low-bore axis design changes how recoil feels, especially with .357 loads that normally snap your wrist in a small revolver.

It’s not a traditional trigger feel, and the looks are polarizing. Still, in terms of staying on target and running quick follow-up shots, it does things older designs struggle to match without just adding more weight.

15. Manurhin MR73 (modern production)

The MR73 is what you buy when you want “best” and you’re willing to pay for it. The fit and finish are on another level, but the real story is endurance. These guns are known for handling a steady diet of .357 without shooting loose.

For the guy who actually shoots his nice revolver instead of polishing it, that matters. It’s not a budget-friendly recommendation, but it’s a real example of modern revolver building done with zero shortcuts.

16. Taurus 856 (Defender models)

Taurus has had ups and downs, and anybody pretending otherwise is selling something. But the 856, especially in the current Defender-style trims, hits a sweet spot: six rounds of .38 +P in a size that still carries comfortably.

The sights and grip options are better than what a lot of older small-frames ever offered. For a practical glovebox-to-belt revolver (secured appropriately), it’s hard to argue with the utility, especially at the price.

17. Taurus 605 (steel-frame variants)

A small .357 is always a compromise, and the 605 is no exception. The reason it’s on this list is simple: in steel form, it’s one of the more affordable ways to get a real .357 snub that can be practiced with.

Will it feel like a full-size gun? No. But if you keep your loads sensible, shoot enough to verify reliability, and don’t pretend physics won’t show up, it’s a workable modern option that gets carried a lot.

18. Taurus Judge Executive Grade

The Judge platform gets joked about, and some of that is earned. But the higher-end, better-finished versions show what the concept was trying to be: a close-range utility revolver for snakes, pests, and general property chores.

It’s big for the capacity, and it’s not a replacement for a proper defensive handgun. Still, with quality ammunition choices and realistic expectations, it fills a niche some folks actually have around barns and brush piles.

19. Smith & Wesson 627 Performance Center

If you want to talk about a modern revolver that makes older “service revolvers” feel dated, an eight-shot .357 with a tuned action will do it. The 627 Performance Center guns tend to have excellent triggers and usable sights right out of the box.

Eight rounds changes the revolver conversation. For range work, competition, or home defense, that extra capacity matters, and moon-clip capability makes reloads much less of a circus than speedloaders ever were under stress.

20. Smith & Wesson 686 Plus (7-shot)

This is the revolver I’ve seen more “semi-auto only” guys warm up to after a few cylinders. The 686 Plus is heavy enough to be comfortable with magnums, accurate enough to show you what you’re doing wrong, and common enough that holsters and grips aren’t a treasure hunt.

Seven rounds isn’t magic, but it’s a nice bump with no real downside. If you want one revolver that can do range duty, ride in the woods, and still make sense for home defense, the 686 Plus is hard to beat.

Old revolvers deserve respect, and plenty of them still run like tops. But modern wheelguns have gotten tougher, more shootable, and more realistic about how folks actually use them: in bad light, with wet hands, with hot ammo, and with limited time to fuss. Pick the one that fits your life, shoot it enough to trust it, and don’t confuse nostalgia with performance.