Shotguns That Collectors Are Quietly Adding to Their Lists Before the Market Figures Them Out

Photo credit: mrsmel269/Youtube

There’s a certain kind of shotgun that sits in the corner of a gun room and never gets talked about online. It’s not “tactical.” It’s not the latest Turkish import with a dozen model names. It’s the one that has been quietly doing work for 40 years, and suddenly the guys who pay attention are buying them up when they see a clean one.

This isn’t about museum-grade engraved doubles. It’s about shotguns that still make sense in the field, still have parts support (or are built so simply they don’t need much), and still feel like “real” guns when you run them. If you’ve ever sold one to fund the next shiny thing and regretted it later, you already understand the game.

1. Remington 870 Wingmaster (older, high-polish blued guns)

Every time I pick up an older Wingmaster, I’m reminded how slick an 870 can actually feel. The action bars are smooth, the finish is deep, and the gun just points like it’s supposed to. A lot of modern pump guns run fine, but they don’t have that same “oiled glass” cycle when they’re broken in right.

Collectors are sniffing these out because the older ones have a fit-and-finish you don’t see at big-box counters anymore. They’re also still hunting-useful: swap chokes, run light loads, carry it all day, and it doesn’t complain. Clean examples with nice wood don’t sit long when someone knows what they’re looking at.

2. Remington 1100 (12 gauge field models)

The 1100 is one of those guns that makes you shoot better than you deserve on a tired day. Soft recoil, steady swing, and it doesn’t beat you up during a long afternoon of clays or late-season pheasants. The right one feels like it grew out of your shoulder.

Yes, it’s a gas gun, and yes, O-rings are a thing. But the parts are common, the knowledge base is everywhere, and when they’re maintained they run. The older, honest field guns are getting harder to find because the “just one more” crowd keeps snagging them.

3. Remington 11-87 Premier (walnut, vent-rib hunting guns)

The 11-87 lived in that awkward space where it wasn’t “classic enough” for some folks and wasn’t “modern enough” for others. That’s exactly how sleepers happen. The Premier models in particular tend to have nicer wood and a solid feel without getting too precious to carry.

They’re not perfect, and they don’t need to be. They’re a practical semi-auto for a guy who hunts, shoots a bit, and doesn’t want to baby a $2,000 shotgun. When you find one that’s been cleaned instead of abused, it’s a buy-it-now situation.

4. Browning A-5 (Belgian-made, humpback classics)

The humpback Browning is pure history you can still hunt with. They carry their weight in a way that swings naturally, and the whole gun has that old-world mechanical confidence. You either love the feel, or you don’t, but you can’t pretend it’s not its own thing.

The Belgian guns especially have been creeping upward because collectors know what they are. Even if you never “collect,” you’re still buying a shotgun that holds its place in the safe. Just pay attention to condition and don’t assume every A-5 was treated kindly.

5. Browning BPS (20 gauge, bottom-eject)

Bottom-eject sounds like a gimmick until you hunt in nasty weather or you’re a lefty who’s tired of eating hulls. The BPS is also built like a fence post. Heavy? Sure. But it’s the kind of heavy that makes a gun feel steady when you’re swinging through a crossing bird.

Collectors and practical hunters overlap here. A clean 20 gauge BPS makes a near-perfect woods and field pump, and they don’t pop up used as often as you’d think. When someone finds one with a smooth action and decent wood, it tends to go home with them.

6. Ithaca 37 (pre-1975, slick action guns)

The Ithaca 37 is one of the best-carrying pumps ever made. It’s slim, it points fast, and the bottom-eject keeps things tidy. In thick grouse cover or tight quail stuff, that “alive in the hands” feel matters.

Older ones have a reputation for being smooth, and the good ones really are. The trick is finding one that hasn’t been neglected or “kitchen-table modified.” When you do, you’re looking at a shotgun that’s both a field tool and an underappreciated classic.

7. Winchester Model 12 (field grades, honest wear)

If you’ve never run a Model 12 that’s been used but not abused, you should. The action has a certain weight and glide to it that modern pumps just don’t have. It’s not nostalgia; it’s machining and time.

These are already respected, but the quiet move is buying field-grade guns that aren’t collector-perfect. They’re still affordable compared to high-grade versions, and they’re still excellent hunters. A Model 12 with good bones is the kind of gun you keep for life.

8. Winchester Model 42 (.410)

.410s get a lot of talk, and most of it is nonsense. They’re not “easy.” But the Model 42 is one of those .410s that makes you want to practice, because it’s balanced and built right. It’s a small-bore that doesn’t feel like a toy.

These have been climbing for a while, but the really clean field guns are getting snapped up fast. A lot of them were treated like kid guns, which means they got knocked around. Find one that wasn’t, and you’ll understand why collectors keep putting them away.

9. Mossberg 500 “Persuader” (older, metal trigger guard era)

The defensive 500 isn’t a rare bird, but older examples with the metal bits and decent fit are getting attention. They’re reliable, simple, and they don’t mind living behind a truck seat or in a closet as long as you store them responsibly.

What makes them collectible isn’t fancy engraving—it’s configuration and condition. Older short-barrel setups, especially with factory parts intact, are showing up less. A clean, un-messed-with example is more interesting than the internet gives it credit for.

10. Mossberg 835 Ulti-Mag (early production waterfowl guns)

The 835 has put a lot of geese on the ground, and it did it before “super magnum everything” became the marketing line. It’s a big, honest, hard-working gun. Not pretty. Not light. Just capable.

Early guns that weren’t beat to death in boat bottoms are starting to stand out. If you find one with a good bore, tight lockup, and no backyard camo job, you’ve got a waterfowl piece with real history and real use left.

11. Benelli Super Black Eagle (original SBE, first generation)

The original SBE is one of those shotguns that changed what people expected from a semi-auto in bad weather. It runs when it’s cold, wet, and miserable. It’s also a gun a lot of guys used hard, which means clean ones matter.

New Benellis are great, but the first-generation guns have their own following. If you hunt coastal marsh or late-season fields and you want a “just works” inertia gun, the old SBE has a pull. Collectors like them because they’re a milestone, not a fad.

12. Benelli M1 Super 90 (field and practical configurations)

The M1 is the kind of shotgun that makes you wonder why you ever messed around with finicky guns. Simple inertia system, good balance, and a reputation for taking abuse and still showing up ready. A lot of them lived hard lives in blinds and patrol cars.

That’s why clean M1s get scooped up quickly. They’re not “rare,” but they’re becoming less common in unmolested condition. If you find one that hasn’t been drilled, tapped, chopped, or otherwise “improved,” it’s worth a serious look.

13. Beretta 303 (classic gas semi-auto)

The Beretta 303 doesn’t get talked about like it should. It’s a smooth shooter with a reputation for reliability, and it has that old Beretta feel—light enough to carry, steady enough to hit with. The lines are clean, too, which never hurts.

These are creeping into that sweet spot where they’re old enough to be appreciated and still modern enough to be practical. Parts and service knowledge are out there. If you see one with good wood and a clean gas system, you might not see it again.

14. Beretta AL390 (12 gauge field guns)

The AL390 was the “regular guy” Beretta for a long time. It’s not flashy, and that’s probably why it gets overlooked. But it’s soft shooting, dependable, and it handles a variety of loads without being temperamental.

What’s happening now is the same thing that happens to a lot of good tools: the folks who know start buying them before everyone else decides they’re cool. A clean AL390 is a do-it-all semi-auto that doesn’t need to prove itself on the internet.

15. Franchi 48 AL (lightweight, long-recoil semi-auto)

The 48 AL is not for everyone. It’s light, it’s a long-recoil design, and it has its own personality. But if you’ve ever carried one all day in the uplands, you get why it has a loyal following. It’s a mountain gun without mountain-gun pricing—at least for now.

Collectors like them because they’re different and they’re genuinely useful. The trick is finding one that hasn’t been neglected, because light guns often get tossed around. When you find a good one, it’s a shoulder-friendly carry and a conversation piece.

16. CZ-USA Bobwhite G2 (side-by-side that’s actually used)

Side-by-sides have a way of turning into safe queens, but the Bobwhite G2 is the opposite. It’s a working man’s double that you can take into briars and not get weird about it. Straightforward, points nice, and it doesn’t pretend to be a London best gun.

These are getting more attention because the market has gotten silly on “classic” doubles. The Bobwhite sits in a sane lane: functional, affordable, and enjoyable. If you want a double you’ll actually hunt with, this is one that keeps getting quietly picked up.

17. SKB 585 (over/under field guns)

SKB over/unders have been a sleeper for years. They tend to balance well, they’re not outrageously heavy, and they’ve filled a lot of dove fields without complaint. You’ll see them in racks owned by guys who shoot a lot but don’t talk much.

The 585 in particular is a “buy it used and be happy” kind of gun. Condition matters, as always, and you want tight lockup. When you find one that’s been cared for, you’re getting quality without the premium-name tax.

18. Ruger Red Label (early production 12 gauge)

The Red Label has always been a little polarizing. Some folks think it’s chunky. Others love that it’s tough and American-made. I’ve carried them enough to say this: they’re not dainty, but they’re honest.

Early guns and clean examples have been getting pulled into collections because Ruger isn’t making them the same way now. They’re also real hunting over/unders, not just range toys. If you see one with decent wood and a tight feel, don’t assume they’ll always be sitting there.

19. Browning Citori Lightning (20 gauge, field-friendly O/U)

If there’s a “safe bet” over/under that still feels like a good buy used, it’s a 20 gauge Citori Lightning. They point well, they’re durable, and they handle the kind of high-volume shooting that breaks lesser guns. The Lightning profile just carries nicely, too.

This one isn’t unknown, but it’s still being quietly vacuumed up in the used market. The reason is simple: they’re useful and they last. A clean 20 gauge that hasn’t been shot loose is the kind of gun a guy buys once and stops shopping.

20. Savage/Stevens 311 (utility side-by-side)

There is nothing fancy about a 311, and that is kind of the point. They’re the farm doubles that got leaned in a corner, rode behind a truck seat, and still went hunting. They’re not refined, but they’re real.

Collectors are starting to appreciate “working-class American” guns, and the 311 fits that bill. Clean ones are harder to find because most were used exactly as intended. If you find one that locks up tight and hasn’t been messed with, it’s a cool piece of everyday history you can still take to the woods.

The market always figures things out eventually. When it does, the boring-but-good shotguns stop being boring and start being expensive. If you’re hunting for one of these, focus on condition, originality, and whether it actually fits what you do—because the best collectible shotgun is still the one you’re not afraid to carry when the weather turns ugly.